Wine Reviews from The Wine News
tasters' choice selections
94 M. Chapoutier, 2001 La Sizeranne
Hermitage, France
Deep garnet hue. Big, barnyardy aromas of blackberry, leather and smoke. Intense, silky, layered flavors of black currant, sweet oak and milk chocolate are rich and concentrated without being hot. An apt blend of the traditional and modern Hermitage. Sweet, opulent finish. $97
94 Grace Family Vineyards, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Purple-black hue. Tight, dusty, complex aromas of black cherry, plum, minerals, cedar, tobacco and menthol. Supple, minerally, well-balanced flavors of blackberry, plum, espresso, redwood and mocha. Black fruit and coffee frame the lengthy close. $190 (mailing list only)
93 Casa Lapostolle, 2002 Clos Apalta
Limited Release, Apalta Vineyard, Colchagua, Chile
Opaque purple hue. Heady scents of blackberry, milk chocolate, coconut and a floral note. Soft, chalky flavors of black cherry, cassis, chocolate and ample oak. Plenty of mint and clove in the lingering finish. $65
best value selections
90 Paul Jaboulet Aîné, 2003 Parallèle "45"
Côtes-du-Rhône, France
Ruby-black hue. Earthy aromas of plum, dried herbs and tar. Extracted flavors of sweet black currant, licorice and minerals. Wood spice and oak in the warm close. A lot of heft for the price. $10
90 Domaine Jean Bousque, 2004 Malbec
Tupungato, Mendoza, Argentina
Vibrant purple hue. A heady, aromatic bouquet emitting raspberry, tar and a whiff of chocolate. Juicy and rich with layers of black cherry, mocha and mineral flavors. A classic example of Argentine Malbec. Ripe, exotic finish. $10
89 Montes, 2003 Reserve, Malbec
Oak Aged, Central Valley, Chile
Ruby hue. Perfectly varietal aromas of plum, leather, smoke and red meat. Plush yet spicy flavors of blackberry, earth and milk chocolate. Citrusy close. $10
publisher's pick
93 Origin Napa, 2002 Heritage Sites
Napa Valley
Youthful purple hue. Forward aromas of plum, mint and vanilla. This dynamic, merlot-based wine offers layers of plum, black cherry and mineral flavors. Chocolate and clove add complexity to the fruit-driven finish. A well-made wine, attractive in its youth. 892 cases / $35
Editor's Note: In order to include more BuyLine reviews for the 20th Anniversary issue, a wine scoring 86 points or less is listed at the foot of its category without a note.
California
Chardonnay
88 Cosentino Winery, 2003 Chardonnay
Napa Valley
Brilliant yellow-gold hue. Ripe aromas of honey, cream and caramel. Supple texture with flavors of oak, apple and pineapple. Lengthy finish with a continuation of the apple and oak theme. $22
88 Dutton Goldfield, 2003 Chardonnay
Dutton Ranch, Russian River Valley
Bright yellow hue. A bouquet of fresh carnations, sliced apple and honey. Supple texture with peach, apple and cinnamon flavors. Crisp close. $30
89 Franciscan Oakville Estate, 2002 Chardonnay
Wild Yeast, Cuvée Sauvage, Carneros, Napa Vly
Shiny gold hue. Toasted aromas of citrus, butterscotch and clove. Racy, minerally flavors of grapefruit, lemon, butterscotch and charred oak. Lingering finish highlighted by honey. $33
88 Gallo of Sonoma, 2002 Chardonnay
Laguna Vineyard, Russian River Valley
Polished yellow hue. Charred oak aromas with citrus playing second fiddle. Exceedingly ripe flavors of grilled pineapple, peach, honey and vanilla. Cinnamon, nutmeg and apple in the close. $22
88 Geyser Peak Winery, 2003 Chardonnay
Reserve, Alexander Valley
Gold hue. Tropical aromas of banana peel, mango, biscuit and a light toastiness. Sweetly ripe flavors of pineapple, peach and charred oak. Tart finish. $25
91 Kendall-Jackson, 2002 Chardonnay
Grand Reserve, Monterey, Santa Barbara, Sonoma
Deep yellow hue. Uplifting aromas of vanilla bean, caramel and grilled pineapple. Generous, honeyed flavors of apple, nectarine, vanilla and peach. Ripe, well-oaked finish. $20
88 Landmark, 2003 Overlook Chardonnay
Sonoma, Monterey, Santa Barbara
Burnished gold hue. Forward, toasty aromas of stone fruit, apple and earth. Supple flavors of peach, apricot and lots of oak. Creamy close. $25
88 Landmark, 2002 Damaris Reserve Chardonnay
Bien Nacido Vineyard, Santa Maria Valley
Yellow-gold hue. Intriguing combination of lime peel, pecan and clove aromas. Flavors of lemon, butter and copious oak. Honey in the finish. $34
88 M. Cosentino, 2003 CE2V Chardonnay
Napa Valley
Bright gold hue. Tropical scents of pineapple, butterscotch and vanilla. Huge, buttery flavors of apricot, mango and honey with just enough acidity to keep it in balance. Soft, sweet finish. $40
92 Marimar Estate, 2002 Dobles Lias Chardonnay
Don Miguel Vineyard, Russia River Valley
Light gold hue. Fresh aromas of honey, nutmeg, oak, clove and resin. Silky texture reflecting butternut, apple and cinnamon flavors with a light mineral accent. Clove and toasted oak mark the close. $40
87 Michel-Schlumberger, 2003 Chardonnay
Dry Creek Valley
Gold hue with a green tint. Light tropical fruit scents with a hint of pencil. Dry citrus and oak flavors. Toasted finish with a note of clove. $26
87 Nickel & Nickel, 2003 Chardonnay
John's Creek, Napa Valley
Shimmering gold-green hue. Shy scents of citrus rind, Meyer lemon and new oak. Flavors of peach, apple and toasted oak. A honey note in the close. $50
90 Nickel & Nickel, 2003 Chardonnay
Truchard Vineyard, Carneros, Napa Valley
Light yellow hue. Floral aromas of lemon, chalk, butter and a confectioner's sugar note. Abundant flavors of banana, grapefruit, honey and guava butter. Long, spicy finish. $38
88 Robert Mondavi Winery, 2002 Chardonnay
Unfiltered, Carneros
Light gold hue with a green tint. Shy scents of lemon, cinnamon and a butter note. Mix of lemon, peach, honey and butterscotch flavors. Dry finish. $25
91 Robert Mondavi Winery, 2001 Chardonnay
Reserve, Napa Valley
Deep gold hue. Ripe, buttery aromas of banana peel, honey, clove and well-integrated oak. A big mouthful of lemon curd, grilled pineapple, honey and charred oak flavors. Long, honeyed close. $39
90 Sebastiani, 2003 Chardonnay
Dutton Ranch, Russian River Valley
Vibrant yellow hue. Peach aromas with an attractive vanillin oak accent. Nectar-like texture with creamy pineapple and peach flavors that finish on a well-oaked note. $25
87 Smith-Madrone, 2002 Chardonnay
Napa Valley
Gold hue. Aromas of vanilla and fresh bread dough. Forward flavors of apple, honey and toffee. Citrus and charred oak dominate the close. $25
88 Stuhlmuller Vineyards, 2003 Chardonnay
Alexander Valley
Pale gold hue. Buttery toasted oak scents. Tasty flavors of apple, caramel and brown spice with an additional oak nuance running through its core. Ready-to-drink finish. $20
87 Villa Mt. Eden, 2002 Chardonnay
California
Reflective gold hue. Bright aromas of apple compote, honey and clove. Ripe apple flavors with cinnamon and vanilla accents. Rich finish. $10
91 Whitford, 2002 Chardonnay
Haynes Vineyard, Napa Valley
White gold hue. Attractive aromas of pecan, honey and pineapple. Silky smooth and sweet with apple, ripe peach and new oak flavors. Clean close with a lively bite of youthful acidity. $20
86 Amberhill, 2003 Chardonnay
California
- $9
86 Anapamu Cellars, 2003 Chardonnay
Barrel Fermented, Monterey County
- $16
86 MacRostie, 2003 Chardonnay
Carnerous
- $20
86 Marcelina Vineyards, 2003 Chardonnay
Carneros
- $24
86 Meridian Vineyards, 2003 Chardonnay
Santa Barbara County
- $10
85 Napa Valley Vineyards, 2003 Chardonnay
Reserve, Napa Valley
- $15
86 Nickel & Nickel, 2003 Chardonnay
Searby Vineyard, Russian River Valley
- $38
86 Robert Mondavi Winery, 2002 Chardonnay
Napa Valley
- $20
85 Silver Ridge, 2003 Chardonnay
Barrel Fermented, California
- $10
Cabernet & Blends
88 Blank, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Medium garnet hue with an orange rim. Cedary aromas of dried red fruit, clove, tea and anise. A fruitcake spiciness adds to flavors of cranberry, sweetened coffee and cardamom. Long close. $30
92 Bravante Vineyards, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Howell Mountain, Napa Valley
Ruby-black hue. Captivating scents of cherry cola, plum and cigar box with an herbal note. Forward flavors of cherry skin, cassis, vanilla and minerals have a plush texture. Finishes quite sweet. $45
92 Caymus Vineyards, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Inky black hue. Dense aromas of blackberry, orange, oak char and iodine. Chalky flavors of blueberry, vanilla, brown sugar and German chocolate cake. Long close shows a trace of tobacco. $70
92 Chateau St. Jean, 2000 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Sonoma County
Black garnet hue with a ruby rim. Ripe plum, rose petal and espresso aromas. Creamy flavors of blueberry, cherry, mocha and graphite. Lasting cherry-chocolate flavors that literally coat, then melt on the palate. $90
89 Chimney Rock, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Vibrant purple hue. Polished aromas of cherry, raspberry, new oak and mint. Tooth-coating flavors of cherry, raspberry, damp earth and a lightening violet nuance. Puckering, spicy finish. $52
92 Clos du Bois, 2001 Marlstone
Alexander Valley
Dense garnet hue. Beautifully integrated aromas of blackberry, cherry, pencil, smoke and a vanilla nuance. Flavors of mixed berries, plum, minerals and chocolate are quite concentrated without being unbalanced. Sweet close shows ample fruit. $50
92 Far Niente, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Oakville, Napa Valley
Inky purple hue. Smoky aromas of black plum, cherry, coffee, mahogany and a pretty violet note. Intense flavors of blackberry, cherry, molasses, bittersweet chocolate and oak char. Long, creamy finish is jammed with fruit. $110
89 Hall, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Deep garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Oak and redwood scents dominate notes of blackberry candy and tar. Flavors of blackberry, milk chocolate and oak are more approachable than the nose suggests. Chocolate-covered black fruit in the close. $35
89 Kendall-Jackson, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Sonoma, Napa, Mendocino
Black-garnet hue. Pungent, cedary aromas of cassis, fig, caramel and coffee. Fresh, lively flavors of blueberry, espresso, charred oak and black pepper. Chalky finish. $26
93 Kunde Estate, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Sonoma Valley
Dense purple hue. Enticing aromas of cherry, rum cake, graphite, mint and dust. Jammy flavors of black fruit, chocolate, earth and eucalyptus. Bracing finish marked by plum and cherry notes. $60
92 M. Cosentino, 2001 CE2V Meritage
Napa Valley
Black hue. Warm, chocolaty aromas of plum, blueberry, maple and cedar. Layered flavors of raspberry, cherry, coffee, mint and a citrus note. Redwood and citrus peel frame the spicy close. $75
90 Merriam Vineyards, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Sonoma County
Purple hue with a garnet rim. Earthy scents followed by notes of blueberry, plum and pencil shavings. Lively, minerally plum flavors with an edgy bell pepper note. Youthful, tannic close. $35
91 Mount Veeder Winery, 2001 Reserve
Napa Valley
Garnet hue. Heady aromas of plum, cassis, Worcestershire sauce and mint. Tooth-coating flavors of blackberry, coffee, German chocolate cake and redwood. Soft, polished finish. $80
91 Niebaum-Coppola, 2001 Rubicon
Rutherford, Napa Valley
Purple hue. Rich aromas of crushed plum, chocolate, lanolin and a sawdust note. Intense flavors of blackberry, cherry, chocolate, tobacco and toasted oak. Lasting sweetness in the Port-like close. $100
91 Origin Napa, 2002 Family Home Cabernet
Grand Reserve, Napa Valley
Black hue with a brick rim. Creamy aromas of plum, huckleberry, dust and cedar. Silky, balanced flavors of roasted plum, cherry, mocha and plenty of earth. Dry, peppery finish. $55
90 Origin Napa, 2002 Paramount
Napa Valley
Black hue with a violet rim. Sweetly ripe aromas of cherry cola, blueberry, vanillin oak and brown sugar. Well-meshed flavors of blackberry, plum and mocha are framed by tooth-coating but not rough tannins. Warm finish sports cherry notes. $65
88 Robert Craig, 2001 Affinity
Napa Valley
Cloudy garnet hue. Warm scents of black cherry, mint, cedar and earth. Flavors of sweet cherry, vanillin oak and dusty tannins make for a nice package. Zesty red fruit in the close. $40
92 Robert Mondavi Winery, 2001 Cabernet
Reserve, Napa Valley
Deep garnet hue. Subtle Old World aromas of plum, cedar, tea, tobacco and coffee grounds. Animated flavors of black cherry, nutmeg, semisweet chocolate and brown sugar. Dried fruit and Asian spices in the taut finish. $125
92 Robert Mondavi Winery, 2001 Cabernet
Oakville, Napa Valley
Deep crimson hue. Nicely restrained aromas of cherry, plum, new leather, pencil and cedar. Integrated flavors of cherry, clove, chocolate and sweet oak. Chocolate-covered fruit in the close. $40
90 Rodney Strong, 2000 Symmetry
Alexander Valley
Dense garnet hue. Generous aromas of sweet blackberry, cassis, mocha and an orange note. Very citrusy flavors of cherry, plum, oak and mint. Quite tangy finish. $55
87 Rodney Strong, 2000 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Sonoma County
Garnet hue. Spicy scents of clove, mint and resin.Youthful red fruit flavors with peppery tannins. Crisp close. $40
90 Rodney Strong, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Alexander's Crown, Alexander Valley
Cloudy garnet hue. Inviting scents of raspberry, cherry, charred oak and tea. Warm flavors of blackberry, brown sugar, chocolate and cedar freshened by lively acidity. Ripe, creamy close. $30
92 Smith-Madrone, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Estate Bottled, Napa Valley
Reddish-black hue. Creamy aromas of cherry, orange peel, brown sugar and ample new oak. Spritzy acidity lifts hefty flavors of ripe black cherry, cassis, dark chocolate and minerals. Intense finish packed with mocha. $35
87 Smith & Wollensky, 2002 Private Reserve
Napa Valley
Unfiltered garnet hue. Aromas of fresh raspberry, cedar and a whiff of mocha. A well-structured food wine with red fruit, cedar and vanilla flavors. Lengthy, well-knit finish. $29
90 Soñador, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Black plum hue. Bright scents of cherry, blackberry, underbrush and dust. Concentrated but supple flavors of fig, plum, pencil and mocha. Hints of berry and leather in the angular close. $75
89 St. Clement, 2001 Oroppas
Napa Valley
Unfiltered garnet hue. Pungent aromas of plum, milk chocolate, earth and clove. Fine grain tannins and fresh acidity frame ample flavors of blackberry, smoke and minerals. Chocolate-laced finish. $50
87 Stags' Leap Winery, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Viscous garnet hue. Roasted coffee bean scents with mocha and leather notes. Cherry-chocolate flavors with big, drying tannins. Tight close; needs time. $35
88 Sterling Vineyards, 2001 SVR Reserve
Napa Valley
Deep garnet hue. Smoky aromas of plum, black cherry and pencil reflect a prickly alcoholic warmth. Tart flavors of brambly cherry, coffee and cedar. Lean finish lightened a bit by a sweet fruit note. $45
87 Stuhlmuller Vineyards, 2001 Cabernet
Alexander Valley
Light ruby hue. Woodsy scents of redwood, resin and evergreen with a cherry note. Oaky flavors of raspberry and cherry. Fruit picks up in the close. $30
87 ZD Wines, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Deep ruby hue. Pungent aromas of blueberry, mushroom and menthol. Lively flavors of citrus, raspberry and eucalyptus. Youthful finish. $42 Merlot
87 Chateau St. Jean, 2000 Merlot
Reserve, Sonoma County
Medium garnet hue with a faded rim. Tight aromas of red cherry and cedar show a vanillin oak nuance. Lean flavors of cassis, earth and cedar box. Close sports sour cherry and earth notes. $90
88 Nickel & Nickel, 2002 Merlot
Harris Vineyard, Oakville-Napa Valley
Medium garnet hue with a violet rim. Tentative aromas of dust and cedar with the fruit in the background. Fleshy flavors of sweet-tart raspberry, cinnamon and vanillin oak. Cherry in the close. $40
89 Nickel & Nickel, 2002 Merlot
Suscol Ranch, Napa Valley
Deep garnet hue. Shy aromas of cherry and cedar. Soft flavors of tangy cherry, orange, sweet oak and a milk chocolate note. Understated, herbaceous close. $50
90 Rutherford Hill, 2002 Merlot
Napa Valley
Medium ruby hue. Admirably restrained scents of red currant, smoke, earth and cedar. Balanced, lively flavors of red berry, leather and an oak char note. Lean finish. $25
86 Kendall-Jackson, 2002 Merlot
Grand Reserve, California
- $26
86 Regusci, 2002 Merlot
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
- $40
France White Burgundy
90 Joseph Drouhin, 2002 Vaudésir Chablis
Chablis Grand Cru
Bright gold hue. Ripe, seamless aromas of pineapple and flint in a mineral-laced framework. Soft flavors of pear, citrus peel and a wisp of smoke. Chalky tartness marks the finish. $70
89 Joseph Drouhin, 2003 Saint-Véran
Saint-Véran
Light straw hue. Lean aromas of lime, kiwi and chalk. Bright flavors of lime peel and minerals are quite tart. Tangy close. $12
88 Joseph Drouhin, 2002 Véro Chardonnay
Bourgogne Blanc
Pale yellow hue. Forward aromas of banana, cream and a touch of oak. Flavors of apple and earth are framed by oak. A light citrus note in the close. $20
88 Joseph Drouhin, 2002 Chassagne-Montrachet
Chassagne-Montrachet
Rich yellow hue. Subdued aromas of lime, earth and minerals. Generous, youthful flavors of green apple, bacon fat and new oak. Long finish. $45
88 Olivier Leflaive, 2003 Saint-Aubin
Saint-Aubin En Remilly Premier Cru
Medium gold hue. A nice dose of toasty oak complements aromas of ripe apple and wood spice. Mineral flavors yield to notes of apple and bacon fat. Oak in the close. $32
85 Christian Moreau, 2003 Chablis
Chablis
- $17
Other Whites
90 M. Chapoutier, 2003 La Bernardine Blanc
Châteauneuf-du-Pape
Bright gold hue. Tight aromas of apricot, honey, white flowers and butterscotch. Youthful, well-balanced flavors of peach, pear, tobacco and cedar. Lingering finish features a cleansing bitter note. $45
92 M. Chapoutier, 2001 Chante-Alouette
Hermitage
Burnished gold hue. Mature aromas of baked apple, butter, nutmeg and bacon fat. Oily textured flavors of orange marmalade, wood spice, beeswax and tea. Honey and baking spice in the long close. $74
89 Domaine Miquel, 2003 Viognier
Vin de Pays d'Oc
Deep yellow hue. Very tropical aromas of banana peel, caramel, butterscotch and a honeysuckle nuance. Flavors of lemon and stone fruit are tight and surprisingly lean. A floral trace in the finish. $15
86 Chanson Père & Fils, 2003 Maison Chanson
Viré-Clessé
- $14
86 M. Chapoutier, 2003 Belleruche Blanc
Côtes-du-Rhône
- $15
Red Burgundy
88 Joseph Drouhin, 2002 Vosne-Romanée
Vosne-Romanée
Medium ruby hue. Perfumed, well-integrated aromas of plum, rhubarb and leather. Lean flavors of strawberry, forest floor and a hint of sweet red berry. Tooth-coatingly dry finish. $48
92 Joseph Drouhin, 2002 Clos des Mouches
Beaune Premier Cru
Bright garnet hue. Peppery, perfumed and powerful aromas of black cherry, cedar and dust. Fresh, lively flavors of mixed berries, oak char, licorice and black pepper. Tingling, youthful close. $75
90 Joseph Drouhin, 2002 Véro Pinot Noir
Bourgogne Rouge
Ruby-fuchsia hue. Warm, pungent scents of plum, cedar and earth. Balanced, peppery flavors of bright red fruit and cedar box. Lean close. $25
86 Chanson Père & Fils, 2002 Pinot Noir
Bourgogne Rouge
- $14
86 Domaine Miquel, 2003 Merlot
Vin de Pays d'Oc
- $10
86 Domaine Miquel, 2003 Syrah
Vin de Pays d'Oc
- $11
Rhône Reds
87 M. Chapoutier, 2001 La Bernardine Rouge
Châteauneuf-du-Pape
Medium garnet hue with a faded rim. Leathery aromas of date, smoked meat and milk chocolate. Minerally flavors of stewed fruit and drying cedar. Smoky close. $37
87 Paul Jaboulet Aîné, 2002 Crozes-Hermitage
Les Jalets, Crozes-Hermitage
Garnet hue. Berry fruit perfumes aromas of grill pan and spicy earth. Tarry flavors of roasted plum and pepper. Citrus freshens the big finish. $16
90 Paul Jaboulet Aîné, 2003 Beaumes-de-Venise
Le Paradou, Côtes-du-Rhône Villages
Deep ruby hue. Intense aromas of cherries jubilee, anise and oak. Silky, balanced flavors of blueberry, espresso, oak and black earth. Long, soft close. $16
86 M. Chapoutier, 2003 Belleruche
Côtes-du-Rhône
- $15
85 Pont d'Avignon, 2003 Côtes-du-Rhône
Côtes-du-Rhône
- $15
Other Reds
87 L'Ostal Cazes, 2002 Rouge
Minervois la Livinière
Rich ruby hue with a fuchsia rim. Warm aromas of blueberry, coconut and vanillin oak. Juicy flavors of blackberry, oak and milk chocolate. Gritty finish. $30
90 Château Rollan de By, 2002 Bordeaux
Médoc Cru Bourgeois
Dense ruby hue. Herbal scents of raspberry, cedar, dust and smoke. Bright, silky flavors of cherry, earth and well-meshed oak. Cedar and bell pepper in the classically styled finish. $32
90 Château Trimoulet, 2001 Bordeaux
Saint-Émilion Grand Cru
Opaque garnet hue. Spicy, youthful aromas of red currant and oak. Balanced flavors of mixed berries, smoke, cedar and a citrus note. Fresh herbs spruce up the close. $29
Spain
Whites
87 Viña Canchal, 2003 Pardina
Ribera del Guadiana
Yellow hue with a green tint. Fresh, clean scents of apple blossom and minerals. Just as clean in the mouth with flavors of white grapefruit and straw. Floral finish. $14
83 Don Álvaro de Luna, 2002 Novuss Albillo
Madrid
- $8
84 Don Álvaro de Luna, 2002 Albillo 1434
Madrid
- $14
85 Legado Muñoz, 2001 Garnacha
Tierra de Castilla
- $12
86 Segura Viudas, 2003 Creu de Lavit Xarel-lo
Penedès
- $15
86 Vinos Jeromín, 2002 Vega Madroño
Madrid
- $6
Cabernet Sauvignon
84 Legado Muñoz, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Tierra de Castilla
- $12
85 Osborne Dominio de Malpica, 2001 Cabernet
Tierra de Castilla
- $13
85 Pañuelo Rojo, 2002 Cabernet-Merlot
Navarra
- $10
86 Pilcar Carredueñas, 1999 Tinto Crianza
Cigales
- $19
Tempranillo
87 Canchal, 2003 Tempranillo
Ribera del Guadiana
Bright garnet hue. Forward aromas of raspberry, black cherry and a pungent earthiness. Soft and accessible with cedar accents and sweet cherry flavors. Ripe close. $6
85 Canchal, 2001 Tempranillo
Crianza, Ribera del Guadiana
Feathered garnet hue. Dominant wood aromas of oak, cedar and redwood with a strawberry note. Spicy flavors of cherry and licorice. Dry, simple finish. $9
90 Diez Llorente, 2002 4 Meses
Ribera del Duero
Solid ruby hue. High-toned aromas of ginger, orange peel and leather. Crisp cherry flavors with oak and ginger accents. Youthful, racy finish has a note of charred oak. $14
88 Garcia Figuero, 2002 Tinto Figuero 4
Ribera del Duero
Crimson hue. Attractive aromas of clove, black cherry, coffee and leather. Lively flavors of cherry and espresso. Bone-dry close. $16
86 Diez Llorente, 2001 Crianza
Ribera del Duero
- $23
85 Diez Llorente, 2002 Tinta del Pais
Ribera del Duero
- $11
86 Valdubón, 2000 Tinta del Pais
Reserva, Ribera del Duero
- $24
Other Reds
87 Alidis, 2001 Tinto Roble
Ribera del Duero
Earthy reddish hue. Caramel, tea and wet stone aromas. Cherry and tea flavors with a note of chocolate. Spicy, woodsy close. $17
87 Montecillo, 1996 Gran Reserva
Rioja
Garnet hue. Brown spice and cedar aromas. Spicy cherry flavors with vibrant oak impressions. Dry finish with fine-grain tannins and a lick of clove. $23
90 Pilcar Carredueñas, 2003 Tinto Roble
Cigales
Vibrant garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Fresh aromas of blueberry, leather and cedar. Juicy black cherry flavors laced with fine-grain tannins. Cherry and mocha punctuate the youthful finish. $14
87 San Juan Bautista, 2003 Yonna
Campo de Borja
Bright garnet hue. Mixed aromas of nutmeg, citrus and clove. Dry and tannic with a solid backbone of crisp red fruit flavors. Youthful, chalky close. $19
87 Señorio de P. Peciña, 1998 Reserva
Rioja
Ruby hue. Aromas of charcoal, licorice, leather and cedar box. Light body with exotic flavors of orange pekoe tea, cherry and tobacco. Dry finish. $30
90 Y Viñedos Alzania, 2002 Alzania Crianza
Navarra
Unfiltered crimson hue. A pungent, earthy bouquet laced with cherry and mocha aromas. Strawberry and cranberry flavors are tart and have rough-hewn tannins. Finishes on a peppery note. $33
86 Alidis, 2000 Tinto Crianza
Ribera del Duero
- $23
85 Bodegas del Medievo, 1998 Medievo Reserva
Rioja
- $17
86 Cavas Hill, 1998 Hill Gran Reserva
Penedès
- $30
83 Legado Muñoz, 2002 Merlot
Tierra de Castilla
- $12
86 Palacio de La Vega, 2000 Conde de la Vega
Navarra
- $20
84 Valcortes, 2003 Red Wine
Rioja
- $10
86 Valdubón, 2003 Red Wine
Ribera del Duero
- $14
86 Zitua, 2000 Crianza
Rioja
- $17
Italy
Whites
87 Enrico Santini, 2003 Campo alla Casa
Bolgheri
Medium gold hue. Bright aromas of pear and minerals. Flavors of banana peel, oak and a freshening dose of grapefruit. Spicy finish. $19
86 Cecchi, 2003 Litorale Vermentino
Maremma Toscana IGT
- $17
Chianti Classico
89 Dievole, 2000 Chianti Classico Riserva
Novecento, Chianti Classico Riserva
Cloudy crimson hue. Nicely integrated aromas of red cherry, plum, mocha and cedar. Vibrant acidity marks flavors of cherry, chocolate and minerals. Just-crushed cherry in the finish. $32
87 Fattoria La Ripa, 1999 Chianti Classico Riserva
Chianti Classico Riserva
Medium garnet hue. Restrained aromas of cherry, citrus peel, earth and oak. Tangy flavors of dried cherry, cedar and clove. Brisk finish. $25
89 La Massa, 2001 Giorgio Prima Chianti Classico
Chianti Classico
Black-garnet hue. Rich aromas of plum, fig, coconut and dust. Extracted flavors of black cherry, plum, wood spice and espresso are well balanced if not particularly Chianti-like. Tooth-coating close. $75
87 Tenimenti Angelini, 1999 Chianti Classico Riserva
Sanleonino, Chianti Classico Riserva
Cloudy garnet hue. Earthy aromas of fig, cherry, iodine and Worcestershire sauce. Hot flavors of cherry, black pepper and a coconut note. Drying finish. $34
85 Dievole, 2001 Chianti Classico
Estate Vintage Selection, Chianti Classico
- $20
86 Fattoria La Ripa, 2001 Chianti Classico
Chianti Classico
- $18
Other Tuscan
88 Castello Banfi, 2002 Rosso di Montalcino
Rosso di Montepulciano
Shiny garnet hue. Warm aromas of brambly black fruit, black pepper and saw dust. Polished tannins deftly frame flavors of blueberry, licorice and coffee. A bell pepper note in an otherwise smooth close. $28
90 Enrico Santini, 2003 Poggio al Moro
Bolgheri
Dense purple hue with a fuchsia rim. Pungent aromas of plum, blueberry, new oak and mint. Very concentrated flavors of blueberry, plum, black earth and chocolate are framed by tooth-coating tannins. Lingering, sweet, fat finish. $24
88 Fattoria La Ripa, 1999 Santa Brigida
Colli della Toscana Centrale IGT
Purple-black hue. A whiff of coconut yields to aromas of cherry blossom and redwood. Lean, minerally flavors of plum, black pepper and new oak. Spicy finish features clove. $22
89 La Massa, 2001 La Massa
Toscana IGT
Black-garnet hue. Wood-dominated aromas of cherry, plum, vanillin oak and cedar. Youthful flavors of ripe cherry, minerals and bittersweet chocolate. Dry close has ample fruit. $37
88 Luigi D'Alessandro, 2003 Syrah
Cortona
Deep garnet hue with a bright violet rim. Well-integrated scents of mixed berries, smoke, cedar and a licorice note. Very earthy flavors of spicy plum are warm and tooth-coating though not rough. Tobacco in the close. $22
87 Tenimenti Angelini, 1999 Tre Rose
Rosso di Montepulciano
Light garnet hue with an orange rim. Mature scents of brown sugar and cedar mask the fruit. Flavors of strawberry, vanilla and clove are fresher than suggested by the nose. Puckering acidity somewhat mars the finish. $14
88 Tenuta Sette Ponti, 2001 Poggio al Lupo
Toscana IGT
Inky garnet hue. Ripe aromas of cherry cola, plum and cedar with a coconut accent. Sweetly earthy flavors of cherry, coffee and redwood. Woody close. $50
89 Villa di Capezzana, 2001 Carmignano
Carmignano
Crimson hue. Aromas of licorice and tar with a bell pepper note that blows off with airing. Very earthy flavors of plum, wood spice and grill pan are quite silky. Long, peppery finish. $33
Other Reds
87 Bottega Vinaia, 2002 Teroldego
Teroldego Rotaliano
Crimson hue. Varietal aromas of plum, earth, tar and tobacco. Flavors of black fruit and licorice are both intense and soft. Food-friendly finish. $21
91 Ceretto, 2000 Barolo Zonchera
Barolo
Light garnet hue with an orange rim. Floral aromas of dried cherry, red licorice, dust and a note of oak. Silky, nicely evolved flavors of black currant, tar, earth and minerals. Sweet fruit in the close. $45
88 Ceretto, 2003 Dolcetto Rossana
Dolcetto d'Alba
Medium ruby hue. Gamy, warm aromas of plum and pencil. Thick, spicy flavors of black currant, licorice and burnt sugar. Chalky finish. $22
89 Foradori, 2002 Teroldego
Teroldego Rotaliano
Brick red hue. Peppery aromas of black plum and earth show the warmth of alcohol. Concentrated flavors of blackberry, espresso and tar have a milk chocolate texture. Long, cedary close. $23
91 Tenuta Sant'Antonio, 1999 Campo dei Gigli
Amarone della Valpolicella
Deep crimson hue. Big aromas of black cherry, balsamic, pepper and cinnamon. Rich, smoky flavors of reconstituted dried cherry, citrus and moist tobacco. Well-polished, lingering finish. $98
87 Vigne Regali, 2003 Dolcetto L'Ardì
Dolcetto d'Acqui
Light ruby hue. Restrained aromas of raspberry and earth with a cedar note. Soft flavors of huckleberry and espresso. Wood spice lifts the finish. $18
86 Ecco Domani, 2003 Merlot
Venezie IGT
- $10
86 Feudo Maccari, 2002 Nero d'Avola
Saia, Sicilia IGT
- $35
Argentina
Whites
85 Bodegas Nieto Senetiner, 2004 Chardonnay
Reserva, Mendoza
- $10
85 Casa Boher, 2003 Sauvignon Blanc
Mendoza
- $11
86 Domaine Jean Bousque, 2004 Chardonnay
Tupungato
- $10
Cabernet & Blends
87 Bodegas Nieto Senetiner, 2002 Cabernet-Shiraz
Reserva, Mendoza
Medium garnet hue. Dusty aromas of sweet red cherry and tobacco. Balanced flavors of cherry and cedar with a black pepper note. Soft close. $10
87 Bodegas Nieto Senetiner, 2002 Don Nicanor
Mendoza
Dense purple hue. Warm, smoky aromas of plum, black cherry and pencil. Citrusy acidity frames flavors of raspberry, mocha and earth. Chocolate in the finish. $15
87 Domaine Jean Bousque, 2003 Cabernet
Tupungato, Mendoza
Bright garnet hue. Forward aromas of cherry, blueberry and a smoky campfire scent. Tart and peppery with plum and blueberry fruit. Lip-smacking finish. $10
85 Antonio Nerviani, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Mendoza
- $16
86 Antonio Nerviani, 2001 Meritage
Reserve, Mendoza
- $16
85 Casa Boher, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Mendoza
- $11
86 Salentein, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Mendoza
- $18
Malbec
88 Bodegas Nieto Senetiner, 2001 Cadmus Malbec
Mendoza
Dense black hue with a violet rim. New oak masks aromas of licorice and tar. Intense flavors of blackberry, citrus and oak. Meaty finish. $37
87 Salentein, 2002 Malbec
Uco Valley, Mendoza
Ruby hue. Forward, spicy aromas of plum, pepper and cedar. Chewy flavors of blackberry and espresso. Smoky close. $18
86 Antonio Nerviani, 2001 Malbec
Reserve, Mendoza
- $16
84 Arriero, 2002 Malbec
Mendoza
- $11
85 Bodegas Nieto Senetiner, 2003 Malbec
Reserva, Mendoza
- $10
86 Casa Boher, 2003 Malbec
Mendoza
- $11
Other Reds
87 Casa Boher, 2003 Merlot
Mendoza
Deep crimson hue with a faded rim. Scents of tobacco, cedar and bell pepper with red fruit in the background. Soft, well-integrated flavors of mixed berries and oak. Lively, citrusy close. $11
87 Domaine Jean Bousque, 2004 Merlot
Tupungato, Mendoza
Black-garnet hue. Fresh aromas of black cherry and mint with a pungent earthiness. Varietal flavors of black cherry, plum and vanilla. Finish shows excellent weight and structure. $10
88 Salentein, 2002 Pinot Noir
Reserve, Uco Valley, Mendoza
Light garnet hue. Mature scents of cherry, smoke and dust. Concentrated flavors of stewed plum, licorice and espresso. Warm, velvety finish. $18
86 Arriero, 2003 Sangiovese
Mendoza
- $11
85 Bodegas Nieto Senetiner, 2003 Merlot
Reserva, Mendoza
- $10
86 Bodegas Nieto Senetiner, 2002 Bonarda
Limited Edition, Mendoza
- $28
83 Casa Boher, 2003 Tempranillo
Mendoza
- $11
86 Pascual Toso, 2003 Merlot
Maipu Vineyards, Mendoza
- $10
86 Salentein, 2002 Pinot Noir
Uco Valley, Mendoza
- $18
86 Salentein, 2002 Syrah
Uco Valley, Mendoza
- $18
Chile
Chardonnay
91 Concha y Toro, 2003 Amelia Chardonnay
Casablanca Valley
Shimmering gold hue. Buttery aromas with a defined grilled pineapple note. Full and creamy with peach, apple and vanilla flavors. Lengthy finish with nectar-like texture and toasted oak character. $35
87 Concha y Toro, 2003 Xplorador Chardonnay
Central Valley
White gold hue with a green tint. Fragrant tropical aromas of banana and pineapple with a sawdust note. Balanced, quaffable flavors of apricot, clove and vanillin oak. Soft close. $7
87 Cousiño-Macul, 2003 Chardonnay
Antiguas Reserve, Maipo Valley
Bright gold hue. Stone fruit aromas. A mix of apricot and grapefruit flavors with lively acidity. Finishes on a sweet note. $13
87 Errazuriz, 2002 Chardonnay
Wild Ferment, Casablanca Valley
Bright yellow hue. Aromas of apple, earth and smoke. Tart flavors of green apple, lime peel and new oak. Somewhat light close. $19
91 Montes Alpha, 2003 Chardonnay
Special Cuvée, Casablanca Valley
Straw gold hue. Ripe, nicely integrated aromas of pineapple and buttery oak. Firm, juicy flavors of banana, pineapple and butterscotch. Banana and mango in the luscious finish. $23
85 Caliterra, 2003 Chardonnay
Reserva, Casablanca Valley
- $13
85 Carmen, 2002 Nativa Chardonnay
Maipo Valley
- $14
85 Concha y Toro, 2003 Chardonnay
Casillero del Diablo, Casablanca Valley
- $9
86 Santa Carolina, 2003 Chardonnay
Barrica Selection, Casablanca Valley
- $13
86 Santa Ema, 2004 Chardonnay
Casablanca Valley, Chile
- $9
86 Terra Noble, 2004 Chardonnay
Casablanca Valley
- $13
86 Veramonte, 2003 Chardonnay
Casablanca Valley
- $9
85 Viña Calina, 2002 Chardonnay
Reserve, Casablanca Valley
- $8
Sauvignon Blanc
88 Concha y Torro, 2004 Terrunyo Sauvignon Blanc
Block 28, El Triangulo Vynd, Casablanca Vly
White gold hue. Pungent herbal scents with a prickly lemon note. Ripe pineapple and vanilla flavors with a contrasting grassiness. Dry, chalky finish. $21
87 Montes, 2004 Fumé Blanc
Reserve, Curico Valley
Pale gold hue. Fresh aromas of pear, bacon fat and smoke. Spritzy acidity frames clean flavors of lime and chalk. Citrus in the close. $10
87 Viña La Rosa, 2004 La Palma Sauvignon Blanc
Cachapoal Valley
Pale straw hue. Scents of grapefruit, lemon and minerals are nicely varietal without being exaggerated. Clean, balanced flavors of lime and chalk. Lots of lime in the finish. $7
86 Santa Carolina, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Special Collection, Rapel Valley
- $7
86 Santa Emma, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Maipo Valley
- $8
85 Terra Noble, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Maule Valley
- $10
85 Walnut Crest, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Central Valley
- $5
Cabernet & Blends
89 Carmen, 2001 Shiraz-Cabernet
Reserve, Maipo Valley
Medium garnet hue. Peppery aromas of blueberry, lavender and licorice. Creamy flavors of black fruit, grilled meat and black pepper. Long, soft finish. $17
90 Casa Lapostolle, 2001 Cuvée Alexandre Cabernet
Apalta Vineyard, Colchagua Valley
Bright garnet hue. Sweet, creamy aromas of cherry, boysenberry, new oak and mint. Minerally flavors of cherry, blueberry, smoked meat, clove and citrus. Spicy finish. $23
88 Concha y Toro, 2001 Don Melchor Cabernet
Puente Ato
Dense crimson hue. Warm aromas of blackberry, cassis, new oak and tar. Concentrated flavors of plum, charred oak and cream soda. Sweet, minty finish shows lots of fruit. $47
90 Cousiño-Macul, 2002 Finis Terrae
Maipo Valley
Unfiltered garnet hue. Reserved aromas of licorice, grilled meat, smoke and tobacco. Lively acidity freshens flavors of cassis, oak spice and black pepper. Complex finish notable for dried tobacco. $20
90 Montes, 2003 Cabernet-Carmenère
Limited Selection, Apalta Vnyd, Colchagua Vly
Bright garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Forward blueberry and pencil aromas. Supple black cherry flavors with an edge of spiciness. Close balanced by a lingering minerality. $16
88 MontGras, 2003 Quatro
Colchagua Valley
Dense garnet hue. Earthy mushroom scents with clove and iodine notes. Rough-hewn tannins with a solid core of cherry flavors. Tart, youthful finish. $16
87 Veramonte, 2002 Primus
Casablanca Valley
Feathered, unfiltered garnet hue. Coffee and oak aromas with a medicinal note. Chocolate flavors with a whiff of minerals and cherry. Firm, tannic finish with a youthful bite. $16
87 Viña Altair, 2002 Altair
Cachapoal Valley
Reddish-black hue. Leathery aromas of rhubarb, iodine and mint. Supple and more expressive in the mouth with flavors of black fruit and smoke. Bittersweet chocolate in the close. $65
89 Viña Caliboro, 2001 Erasmo
Maule Valley
Crimson-black hue. Lively aromas of mixed berries, plum, sweetened coffee and cola. Fruit-forward flavors of cherry, plum, mint and a nice dose of oak. Lasting, citrusy finish. $30
88 Viña Calina, 2003 Alcance Cabernet Sauvignon
Colchagua Valley
Dense garnet hue. Forward cherry-chocolate aromas with a hint of vanilla. Tasty black cherry flavors with earth and oak accents. Youthful, peppery finish. $15
87 Santa Carolina, 2001 VSC
Maipo Valley
Garnet hue. Cedary scents of raspberry, tobacco and wood spice. Dry flavors of strawberry, redwood and briar sweeten up a bit with airing. Toasty close. $35
85 Caliterra, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserva, Colchagua Valley
- $13
83 Lan Zur, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Rapel Valley
- $8
86 Montes, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Oak Aged, Reserve, Colchagua Valley
- $10
85 MontGras, 2003 Cabernet-Syrah
Reserva, Colchagua Valley
- $12
86 MontGras, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Colchagua Valley
- $12
86 Santa Carolina, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Barrica Selection, Maipo Valley
- $13
86 Santa Ema, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Maipo Valley
- $9
86 Terra Noble, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserva, Colchagua Valley
- $10
86 Viña Altair, 2002 Sideral
Rapel Valley
- $25
86 Viña La Rosa, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
La Capitana, Barrel Reserve, Cachapoal Vly
- $12
85 Walnut Crest, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Rapel Valley
- $5 Carmenère
88 Errazuriz, 2003 Carmenère
Don Maximiano Estate, Aconcagua Valley
Purple-garnet hue. Somewhat hot bell pepper and tomato leaf scents overwhelm the fruit. Much friendlier in the mouth with flavors of blackberry, licorice and chocolate. Silky close. $24
89 Santa Carolina, 2003 Carmenère
Barrica Selection, Rapel Valley
Bright ruby hue. Warm aromas of tobacco, earth, smoke and pepper place the fruit in the background. Soft, creamy flavors of plum, licorice and dried tobacco. Lots of licorice in the long finish. $13
87 Terra Noble, 2003 Carmenère
Gran Reserva, Maule Valley
Intense purple hue with a garnet rim. Forward aromas of plum, cherry, pencil and charred oak. Chalky, spicy tart cherry and bell pepper flavors. Crisp, racy finish. $13
89 Viña La Rosa, 2003 Carmenère
La Capitana, Barrel Reserve, Cachapoal Vly
Black hue. Nicely subdued aromas of plum, grill pan and smoke. Supple, earthy flavors of ripe blackberry, espresso and charred oak. Fruit-driven close. $12
82 Santa Ema, 2003 Carmenère
Cachapoal Valley
- $10
85 Terra Noble, 2003 Carmenère
Reserva, Maule Valley
- $10
Merlot
88 Casa Lapostolle, 2002 Cuvée Alexandre Merlot
Apalta Vineyard, Colchagua Valley
Deep ruby hue. Cedary aromas of blackberry, dust and bell pepper. Flavors of blackberry and coffee with a lightening vanilla note. Puckering close. $30
87 Errazuriz, 2003 Merlot
Central Valley
Medium garnet hue. Earthy aromas of plum, tobacco and smoke. Soft, sweet flavors of blackberry and chocolate are round and inviting. Plush finish. $11
87 Terra Noble, 2002 Merlot
Gran Reserva, Maule Valley
Deep garnet hue. Black earth and cherry aromas with a smoky nuance. This is a well-structured Merlot with plum, cherry and dark chocolate flavors. Closes on a tannic note. $10
87 Viña Calina, 2002 Merlot
Reserve, Maule Valley
Light garnet hue. Very pronounced aromas of rhubarb, pencil lead and smoke. Crowd-pleasing flavors of cherry and citrus with integrated wood notes. Ample, fruity close. $8
85 Caliterra, 2002 Merlot
Reserva, Colchagua Valley
- $13
85 MontGras, 2003 Merlot
Reserva, Colchagua Valley
- $11
84 Santa Carolina, 2003 Merlot
Special Collection, Rapel Valley
- $7
86 Santa Ema, 2003 Merlot
Cachapoal Valley
- $9
Other Reds
88 Carmen, 2003 Shiraz
Maipo Valley
Ruby-purple hue. Meaty aromas of ripe blackberry and pepper. Concentrated, very varietal flavors of blackberry, earth and grilled meat. Sweet close. $7
87 MontGras, 2003 Syrah
Limited Edition, Colchagua Valley
Medium purple hue. Subdued aromas of blueberry and violets. Fresh flavors of plum and sweetened coffee show a pleasant softness. Creamy close. $15
88 Santa Carolina, 2003 Syrah
Barrica Selection, Maule Valley
Medium ruby hue. Ripe aromas of blueberry and grill pan are quite peppery. Plush, well-balanced flavors of blackberry and sweet oak. Juicy close. $13
86 Caliterra, 2003 Malbec
Reserva, Colchagua Valley
- $13
85 Cantaluna, 2002 Pinot Noir
Casablanca Valley
- $11
85 Santa Ema, 2003 Syrah
Barrel Select, Cachapoal Valley
- $11
Brunello di Montalcino
The following selection of 2000 Brunello di Montalcino and 1999 Brunello di Montalcino Riserva were reviewed by Contributing Editor Kerin O'Keefe. The wines were tasted February 18 and 19 in Montalcino during the annual Benvenuto Brunello event. The wines were not tasted blind. 91 Biondi Santi , 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Brunello di Montalcino
Vibrant ruby hue. Captivating varietal aromas of flowers and cherry. Bright crushed cherry flavors perfectly balanced by bright acidity and firm tannins. Because no Riserva will be made in 2000, this Brunello was made from the best and oldest vines usually destined for the Riserva. Best in 2010. $130
94 Biondi Santi, 1999 Brunello di Montalcino
Riserva, Brunello di Montalcino
Intense ruby hue with garnet reflections. Enticing scents of spring flowers and rose petals with hints of vanilla and truffle. Lively cherry flavors with notes of licorice and tobacco balanced by fresh acidity and silky tannins. Long finish of crushed cherry with a hint of tobacco. $290
86 Lambardi, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Brunello di Montalcino
Medium ruby hue. Rich scents of violets and cherry. Raspberry and sweet cherry flavors with a licorice hint. Lively tannins mark an earthy close. $60
91 Il Marroneto, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Madonna delle Grazia, Brunello di Montalcino
Intense ruby hue. A cru selection from some of Montalcino's best vineyards. Fruity nose of dark berries and violets. Raspberry flavors balanced by vibrant acidity and firm tannins; lingering finish. $85
91 Il Marroneto, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Brunello di Montalcino
Deep ruby hue. Aromas of dark berries and flowers. Sharp acidity and bracing tannins balanced by tart fruit flavors. Aggressive, but will age gracefully. $75
88 Gianni Brunelli, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Brunello di Montalcino
Deep garnet hue. Delicate aromas of berries and earth. Ripe raspberry flavors. Firmly structured with fresh acidity and solid tannins. Still very youthful and aggressive; best after five years. $80
89 La Fuga, 1999 Brunello di Montalcino Riserva
Le Due Sorelle, Brunello di Montalcino
Dark garnet hue. Lovely floral and cherry nose. Concentrated woodland berry flavors with a vanilla note, kept in balance by bright acidity and silky tannins. Outstanding value. $58
88 Tenimenti Angelini, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Brunello di Montalcino
Dark ruby hue with granite reflections. Floral scents with the suggestion of talcum powder. Tart berry flavors with a hint of vanilla. Sharp acidity and tough tannins make for a firm, austere structure. Best in five years. $54
89 La Gerla, 1999 Brunello di Montalcino Riserva
Brunello di Montalcino
Deep ruby hue. Violet and berry aromas dominate the nose and are accented by a whiff of black pepper. Palate features lots of crushed cherry flavors. Firm structure with sharp acidity and brooding tannins. Needs time; best after 2010. $100
88 Poggio di Sotto, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Brunello di Montalcino
Dark garnet hue. Dusty talcum powder and violet nose opens to reveal berry aromas and a truffle note. Dark cherry flavors with a hint of licorice dominated by brooding tannins. $130
90 Lisini, 1999 Brunello di Montalcino
Ugolaia, Brunello di Montalcino
Dense garnet hue. Concentrated aromas of plum and raspberry. Opulent raspberry and cherry flavors balanced by good acidity and firm tannins. Long finish. $128
90 Salvioni, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
La Cerbaiola, Brunello di Montalcino
Intense ruby hue. Primary violet scents with hints of truffle and vanilla. Tart cherry fruit flavors with puckering acidity and bracing tannins that reveal the wine's firm structure. Austere and tannic; will age gracefully. $135
88 Il Colle, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Brunello di Montalcino
Garnet hue. Delicate aromas of violets and dried rose petals. Woodland berry flavors balanced by sharp acidity and firm tannins. Still young and closed; will improve with more bottle aging. $45
West Coast Case
92 Babcock, 2002 Pinot Noir
Grand Cuvée, Santa Ynez Valley
Fragrant, complex scents of freshly crushed black raspberry and red cherry with hints of rhubarb and white pepper. Silky and elegant on the palate with supple tannins, tasting of deep berry-like fruit that is fully extracted with a minerality and reprise of the white pepper spice. 678 cases/$16
88 Carneros Creek, 2002 Pinot Noir
Grail, Carneros
From a vineyard close to San Francisco Bay planted to twelve different pinot clones, this Grail was carefully selected from 20 separate lots, producing a generous, full-throttle Pinot with aromas of ripe strawberry and cassis accented by subtle oak char. Nicely extracted flavors match the nose; finishes with a wisp of vanilla. 480 cases/$40
88 Chateau St. Jean, 2002 Pinot Noir
Durell Vineyard, Sonoma Valley
Attractive, lightly perfumed scents of cola, cherry-strawberry fruit, jasmine and vanilla. Juicy, round and silky with firm but supple tannins, the wine coats the palate with sour cherry-cassis fruit enhanced by hints of rhubarb and cinnamon. The spice matches the fruit in finish. 800 cases/$45
93 Merry Edwards, 2002 Pinot Noir
Meredith Estate, Sonoma Coast
Forward aromas of freshly crushed wild strawberry, a mushroom earthiness and dried herbs. Lots of extract in this quintessential Sonoma Coast Pinot, which exhibits strawberry-cassis fruit and a velvety texture. Luscious and complex, it will benefit from a couple of years of cellaring. 650 cases/$48
92 Hartford Court, 2002 Pinot Noir
Arrendell Vineyard, Russian River Valley
Enticing Burgundian nose of forest floor, ripe strawberry-cassis fruit, brown spice and minerals. Round, plush and juicy in the mouth, this seamless, velvety Pinot delivers the flavors promised by the nose, emphasizing a decadent mushroom richness. 327 cases/$65
91 Gary Farrell, 2002 Pinot Noir
Rochioli Vineyard, Russian River Valley
Forward aromas of freshly crushed wild strawberry, black cherry and brown spice. Curvaceous and silky smooth with layers of strawberry-black cherry fruit and spice framed by just the right accompaniment of oak. This is an elegant rendering of Pinot that displays generous acidity emerging in the lengthy, fruit-filled finish. 391 cases/$50
91 Lynmar, 2002 Quail Cuvée Pinot Noir
Quail Hill Vineyard, Russian River Valley
Forward, slightly smoky nose of brandied cherry, blackberry, cola, clove spice and a violet note that appears with airing. Well structured with finely grained tannins and firm acidity, this luscious, richly flavored Pinot is exquisitely varietal, delivering layers of black fruit and brown spice; long finish.355 cases/$40
89 Murphy-Goode, 2002 Pinot Noir
Russian River Valley
Attractive scents of ripe strawberry enhanced by an interplay of forest floor earthiness, white pepper and minerality. An elegant, medium-bodied Pinot that's plush and silky with medium tannins and deep flavors that replicate the nose; finishes with a touch of vanilla. 720 cases/$30
90 Patz & Hall, 2003 Pinot Noir
Burnside Vineyard, Sonoma Coast
Produced entirely from Dijon clone 115. Offers forward, lifted aromas of red berries and vanilla enhanced by allspice and a touch of coconut. Very smooth, round and luscious on the palate with medium tannins and crisp acidity that deliver copious red fruit flavors. 238 cases/$60
89 Patz & Hall, 2003 Pinot Noir
Hyde Vineyard, Carneros
Slow-to-evolve nose of ripe strawberry, roses and red cherry. Full bodied, velvety and luscious, displaying elegance and finesse with nicely concentrated fruit-focused flavors of cassis and strawberry. 1,011 cases/$50
90 Toad Hall, 2003 Pinot Noir
Dijon Clones, Carneros
Very fragrant nose of raspberry, nutmeg and crushed graham cracker. Medium-full bodied with supple, fine-grained tannins, this stylish Pinot delivers deep flavors that replicate the nose and finishes with a smoke note. 280 cases/$40
92 Williams-Selyem, 2002 Pinot Noir
Allen Vineyard, Russian River Valley
Exotic scents of sandalwood-tinged strawberry, Bing cherry, rose petals and crème brûlée, accented by a note of red meat. Plush and rich with great acid balance, this is a mouth-filling Pinot with copious black cherry-raspberry fruit, accented by notes of roasted coffee bean and sweet oak. 445 cases/$15
- Steve Pitcher
About the BuyLine Panel: More than 100 wines are reviewed in every issue of The Wine News. All wines are tasted double-blind and each entry is evaluated and scored based upon individual merit. Wines that score above 70 points are recommended in the BuyLine. Tasting and interpreting wine is a purely subjective exercise; all scores and accompanying tasting notes represent the collective opinions of our panel.
Wine Samples: Send samples for review with retail price affixed to:
The Wine News BuyLine Tasting Panel
1501 Venera Avenue, Suite 320
Coral Gables, FL 33146
Telephone: 305.740.7170
The Panel: Maurice Adams, specialty food and wine merchant; Lyn Farmer, senior staff columnist; Abraham Horowitz, BuyLine panelist; Tom E. Smith, publisher; John Stroker, BuyLine panelist; Fred Tasker, Miami Herald wine critic; Todd M. Wernstrom, executive editor.
Scoring: Tasting notes reflect the panel's collective impressions; scores are averaged and represent the panel's mean. Wines possessing certain criteria will be singled out for special recognition:
Taster's Choice: Wines which display outstanding quality, character and potential.
Best Value Wines of exceptional quality which sell at a moderate price.
Stemware: Riedel Ouverture tasting glasses.
Pricing: Prices vary from state to state. Retail prices listed are approximate.
