Wine Reviews from Wine News
tasters' choice selections
94 Rancho Zabaco, 2003 Zinfandel
Monte Rosso Vineyard, Sonoma County
Deep ruby hue. Very fragrant aromas of raspberry preserves, cherry and cinnamon display laser-like clarity. Substantial flavors of cherry, bramble and cedar. Tart red fruit finish. $35 / 800 cases
93 Quivira, 2002 Zinfandel
Anderson Ranch, Dry Creek Valley
Brooding purple hue. Heady and forthcoming aromas of cherry-chocolate and ripe plum. Stylish and well-stuffed with peppery raspberry and cherry flavors wrapped in a youthful, tannic cloak. Excellent length; great depth of fruit in the finish. $30
92 Peachy Canyon, 2003 Zinfandel
Old School House, Paso Robles
Bright ruby hue. Big, ripe aromas of blueberry, oak char and bittersweet chocolate. Ample flavors of chocolate-covered blackberry, tar, pencil and espresso show excellent balance. Spicy, smoky close. $26
best value selections
90 Montes, 2004 Chardonnay
Barrel Fermented, Curicó Valley, Chile
Deep gold hue. Nicely integrated aromas of pineapple, honey, butterscotch and clove. Big flavors of apricot, pear, oak char and butter are kept fresh by ample acidity. Lasting sweetness in the intensely fruity close. $10 / 32,000 cases
90 Hacienda Araucano, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Central Valley, Chile
Light gold hue with a green tint. Aromas of lime and grass are very varietal without being exaggerated. Brightly fresh flavors of kiwi and green chili show enviable restraint and balance. Juicy finish. $10
90 Willamette Valley Vineyards, 2004 Pinot Gris
Oregon
White gold hue. Aromas of fresh pear and sliced apple. Ripe pear and nectarine flavors exhibit excellent weight and mouth-feel. Enjoyable, lengthy close displays a youthful tartness. $15
publisher's pick
97 Marston Family Vineyards, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Spring Mountain District, Napa Valley
The panel awarded the 2001 95 points, yet the '02 is even better. Inky, intense purple hue. Bursts of mint and blueberry aromas followed by plum, coconut and olive scents. A prototypical mountain Cab with layers of cherry, plum and mineral flavors that kept improving with air. Polished tannins and crisp acids elevate the hillside fruit. $80 / 500 cases
California
Cabernet & Blends
88 Blackstone, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Dry Creek Valley
Black hue with a fuchsia rim. Big, dusty aromas of black fruit, coconut and treacle. Very earthy flavors of macerated plum and pencil. Minerally close. $28
87 Bravante Vineyards, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Howell Mountain, Napa Valley
Garnet hue. Dusty scents of blackberry, mint and bell pepper. Chalky flavors of mixed berries, chocolate and brown spice. Vanillin oak lifts the finish. $45
91 Chatom Vineyards, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Calaveras County
Deep garnet hue. Pretty aromas of black currant, anise, gravel and wild flowers. Silky, concentrated flavors of plum, espresso and minerals. Tingly finish features bittersweet chocolate. $20
88 Eberle, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Vineyard Selection, Paso Robles
Deep crimson hue. Perfumed scents of strawberry and vanillin oak. An affable combination of red berry, earth and mocha flavors. Lively close. $17
89 Eberle, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Estate Bottled, Paso Robles
Black-garnet hue. Rustic aromas of black plum, tar and charred oak. Warm flavors of blackberry, Worcestershire sauce and licorice. Semisweet chocolate in the finish. $26
90 Kendall-Jackson, 2002 Hawkeye Mtn Cabernet
Alexander Valley
Purple-black hue. Minty aromas of raspberry, smoke, tobacco and bell pepper. Sweet, weighty flavors of cherry, brown sugar and espresso. Fruit and cinnamon highlight the close. $45
88 Kendall-Jackson, 2000 Stature Cabernet
Limited Release, Napa Valley
Ruby-black hue. Dusty aromas of rhubarb, clove, pencil and milk chocolate. Minerally, chalky flavors of red fruit, espresso and oak are a touch hot. Spicy redwood in the close. $100
88 Markham, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Unfiltered garnet hue. Big aromas of cherry and roasted coconut. Flavors of mixed berries, orange zest and cedar are quite tangy and mouth-filling. Fresh raspberry marks the finish. $28
90 Robert Craig, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Howell Mountain, Napa Valley
Black cherry hue. Ripe aromas of cherry, menthol, coffee and smoke sport a floral nuance. Muscular flavors of blackberry, plum and bittersweet chocolate are softened by luscious tannins. Fat, juicy finish. $50
88 Trinchero, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Chicken Ranch Vnyd, Rutherford, Napa Vly
Purple-violet hue. Pungent aromas of blackberry, smoke and sweet oak. Flavors of cherry, orange zest, tar and earth. Long finish shows ample fruit. $25
88 Trinchero, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Main Street Vineyard, St. Helena
Black hue with a purple tint. Ripe aromas of blackberry, pencil lead, earth and cedar. Flavors of black fruit and minerals are leaner than suggested by the nose. Earthy close. $40
90 Trinchero, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Lewelling Vineyard, Napa Valley
Purple-black hue. Earthy aromas of blackberry, tobacco and new oak. Intense but very inviting flavors of plum, pencil lead, oak char and bittersweet chocolate. Semisweet chocolate lightens the considerable finish. $45
86 Twin Fin, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
California
Garnet hue. Deep aromas of black currant, smoke and vanillin oak. Ripe blackberry flavors have a cherry skin texture. Sweet close. $10
88 William Hill, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Napa Valley
Deep ruby hue. Pungent aromas of black fruit, wet gravel, earth and cedar. Intense flavors of blackberry, pencil lead and black pepper. Lingering finish. $36
85 Dog House, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Checkers' Cab, California - $9
85 Firestone Vineyard, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Santa Ynez Valley - $18
Merlot
87 Beringer, 2002 Merlot
Founders' Estate, California
Bright garnet hue. Lively aromas of cherry, mineral and cola. Well-integrated flavors of blackberry and earth marked by tart tannins. Dry close. $11
89 Blackstone, 2002 Merlot
Napa Valley
Purple hue with a fuchsia rim. Reserved aromas of cherry, blackberry, oak and cola. Concentrated, minerally flavors of black cherry, maple and vanilla are kept lithe by a citrus note. Creamy finish. $17
87 Blackstone, 2001 Merlot
Reserve, Sonoma County
Deep crimson hue. Ample new oak marks warm aromas of cranberry and earth. Flavors of cherry, citrus, pencil and smoke. Mouth-filling finish. $28
86 Blackstone, 2002 Merlot
Sonoma County
Cloudy red hue. Warm, herbal aromas of rhubarb and new oak. Sweet flavors of plum and brown sugar. Extremely tangy close. $16
90 Bravante Vineyards, 2002 Merlot
Howell Mountain, Napa Valley
Dusty reddish hue. Pungent aromas of sweet plum, cherry and wood spice with a bell pepper note. Polished flavors of raspberry, cherry and vanilla are thick and rich. Very tangy close is packed with fruit. $30
89 Chappellet, 2001 Merlot
Napa Valley
Black-garnet hue. Cedary aromas of plum, dust and wood spice. Balanced, intense flavors of black fruit, baker's chocolate, earth and lots of pencil. Lean, laser-like finish. $28
87 Chateau St. Jean, 2002 Merlot
California
Purple-black hue. Muted aromas of plum, oak and a floral note. Silky flavors of blackberry, chocolate and espresso. Fruit and smoke in the close. $15
87 Clos du Bois, 2002 Merlot
Reserve, Alexander Valley
Ruby hue. Shy, floral scents of strawberry and dust. Flavors of plum, cedar and minerals are much more forthcoming than the nose. Drying finish. $22
86 ForestVille, 2003 Merlot
California
Bright fuchsia hue. Fresh, fruity scents of boysenberry and cedar. Lively flavors of blueberry and vanilla are pleasant if not particularly varietal. Mocha marks the close. $6
87 Franciscan, 2002 Merlot
Oakville Estate, Napa Valley
Garnet hue. Aromas of boysenberry, mint, black pepper and earth. Minerally flavors of blackberry, walnut and chocolate. Peppery finish. $22
88 Frei Brothers, 2003 Merlot
Reserve, Dry Creek Valley
Crimson hue. Smoky aromas of roasted plum and charred oak. Lively flavors of just-picked raspberry and minerals. A whiff of smoke in the close. $20
90 Frog's Leap, 2002 Merlot
Napa Valley
Dense red hue. Pungent aromas of mocha, dust and mint place the fruit in the background. Lively flavors of raspberry, tobacco and chocolate are nicely understated. Oak frames the finish. $34
86 Gainey, 2001 Merlot
Santa Ynez Valley
Medium ruby hue. Aromas of cranberry, new oak and smoke. Dry flavors of raspberry and lots of wood are quite tart. Orange peel in the finish. $19
89 Hall, 2002 Merlot
Napa Valley
Vibrant garnet hue. Intense aromas of cherry, mint and dust with a hint of citrus. Grapy flavors of plum, rhubarb, coffee and a dash of smoke. Sweetness picks up in the close. $28
91 Hartwell Vineyards, 2002 Merlot
Stags Leap District
Reddish hue. Concentrated aromas of black currant, cherry, espresso, minerals and dusty oak. Very intense flavors of cherry, plum, tar, just-turned earth and cedar have great heft without being overwrought. Layered close of fruit and pecan. $65
87 Jessup Cellars, 2001 Merlot
Mt. Veeder, Napa Valley
Medium garnet hue. Cedary aromas of ripe cherry and wet stone. Crowd-pleasing, just-picked strawberry flavors. Fruity finish. $36
90 Kendall-Jackson, 2002 Taylor Peak Merlot
Bennett Valley
Purple to the rim. Intense aromas of blueberry, espresso, pencil and oak. Flavors of cooked cherry, mulberry, brown sugar and vanillin oak are sweeter than hinted at by the nose. Melded fruit and oak grace the close. $35
89 Kendall-Jackson, 2000 Stature Merlot
Limited Release, Sonoma County
Black-garnet hue. Herbal aromas of tobacco, spicy cedar and mocha leave the fruit in the background. Nicely structured flavors of blackberry, chocolate and espresso. Viscous finish. $60
88 Kenwood, 2002 Merlot
Jack London Vineyard, Sonoma Valley
Ruby hue. Scents of cherry, shoe polish, pencil and char. Smoky flavors of black fruit, brown sugar, earth and a beautiful rose note. Bright close. $25
88 Koves-Newlan, 2002 Merlot
Napa Valley
Brick red hue. Dusty aromas of cherry, red berries vanillin oak and a tomato leaf note. Tangy flavors of cherry cola, mint and tea. Vivacious finish. $26
86 Kunde Estate, 2001 Merlot
Sonoma Valley
Ruby hue. Pungent aromas of rhubarb, dust and petrol. Flavors of raspberry, bittersweet chocolate and coconut are more approachable than hinted at by the nose. Citrus and wood in the close. $18
87 Léal Vineyards, 2002 Merlot
Unfiltered, San Benito
Black-garnet hue. Perfumed scents of cherry, vanilla and chocolate. Sweet, creamy flavors of blackberry and tobacco. Slightly bitter finish. $24
88 Lolonis, 2001 Merlot
Redwood Valley
Purple-red hue. Sweet aromas of blackberry, maple and coconut. Dusty flavors of black currant and charred oak display ample acidity. Chocolaty close. $18
89 Madrigal, 2001 Merlot
Napa Valley
Medium ruby hue. Lively, perfumed aromas of red berries and bramble. Friendly tannins announce flavors of cherry, sweet oak and coffee. Lengthy close shows juicy red fruit. $30 Markham, 2002 Merlot 87 Napa Valley Fuchsia-purple hue. Floral aromas of cherry, violets and lavender. Lively acidity brightens flavors of dried cherry, plum and espresso. Cherry-soaked close. $23
86 Montpellier, 2003 Merlot
California
Garnet hue with a violet rim. Warm, pungent aromas of smoke and wood bury the fruit. Sweet flavors of black fruit and brown sugar. Soft finish. $7
87 Napa Cellars, 2002 Merlot
Napa Valley
Medium garnet hue. Sweet, warm aromas of cherry compote and brown sugar. Balanced flavors of red cherry and vanilla. Red fruit powers the close. $19
86 Novella, 2002 Merlot
Paso Robles
Bright purple-red hue. Warm scents of raspberry, pencil and cedar. Chalky flavors of red fruit, redwood and cocoa powder. Dusty finish. $10
88 Pine Ridge, 2001 Merlot
Crimson Creek, Napa Valley
Light red hue. Reserved raspberry scents with a floral note. Nicely balanced flavors of strawberry, mocha and vanillin oak. Spicy close. $27
90 Provenance, 2002 Merlot
Napa Valley
Deep crimson hue. Smoky aromas of blueberry, plum, bittersweet chocolate and tar. Sweet, juicy flavors of plum, mixed berries, earth and espresso. Crisp, youthful finish. $28
87 Raymond Estates, 2002 Merlot
California
Reddish-black hue. Big aromas of blueberry, citrus and smoke. Big-bodied flavors of black fruit, tobacco, bacon fat and lots of earth. Intense close. $15
88 Robert Mondavi Winery, 2001 Merlot
Napa Valley
Black hue. Lean aromas of red currant and oak char. Dry flavors of red fruit, espresso and lots of minerals are very smoothly delivered. Long, earthy finish. $21
86 Silver Ridge, 2003 Merlot
Barrel Select, California
Medium garnet hue. Scents of red berries and dust with an herbal note. Tangy flavors of boysenberry and vanilla. Chocolate moistens the close. $10
87 Simi, 2002 Merlot
Sonoma County
Ruby hue. Inviting aromas of rhubarb and red berries are highly perfumed. Earthy flavors of raspberry and new oak. Peppery finish. $20
88 Stags' Leap Winery, 2001 Merlot
Reserve, Napa Valley
Brick red hue. Warm aromas of rhubarb, menthol and earth. Dry flavors of cherry, oak and minerals. Puckering close features wood spice. $50
87 Talus, 2003 Merlot
Lodi
Medium garnet hue. Integrated aromas of mixed berries and mocha. Tart flavors of brambly red fruit and violets. Drying finish. $8
89 Trinchero, 2002 Merlot
Chicken Ranch Vnyd, Rutherford, Napa Vly
Black-garnet hue. Varietal aromas of plum, cedar and earth. Smooth, balanced flavors of blackberry, pencil and earth. Citrus and cocoa frame the close. $25
88 Wild Horse, 2003 Merlot
Paso Robles
Ruby hue. Sweet aromas of candied cherry, maple and well-meshed oak. Silky flavors of blackberry and earth with an herbal note. Long finish. $20
Zinfandel
88 Charles Krug, 2003 Zinfandel
Napa Valley
Very intense purple hue. Ripe aromas of cherry, evergreen, tobacco and a whiff of bacon. Supple and weighty with lively red fruit, vanilla and toasted oak flavors that linger in the finish. $20
88 Eberle, 2003 Zinfandel
Paso Robles
Cloudy garnet hue. Pretty aromas of cherry, cedar and tobacco. Very earthy flavors of black fruit, campfire and coffee. Brambly, drying finish. $16
90 Eberle, 2003 Zinfandel
Remo Belli Vineyard, Paso Robles
Medium garnet hue. Aromas of red cherry, orange and charred oak. Chalky flavors of strawberry jam, anise and a big dose of oak. Dry, youthful close. $22
86 Edmeades, 2003 Zinfandel
Mendocino County
Dense ruby hue. Briary aromas of raspberry syrup, rhubarb and char. Peppery flavors of cherry and chocolate candy. Soft close. $18
91 Peachy Canyon, 2003 Zinfandel
Especial, Paso Robles
Ruby hue. Floral scents of cherry, citrus, menthol and dust. Powerful, concentrated, yet silky smooth, flavors of blackberry, mocha and coconut. Copious fruit and chocolate in the finish. $30
86 Peachy Canyon, 2003 Zinfandel
Incredible Red, Bin 116, Paso Robles
Cherry hue. Fresh scents of red fruit and dust with an herbal note. Tart flavors of cranberry, rhubarb and earth. A metallic note mars the close. $12
88 Peachy Canyon, 2003 Zinfandel
Mustang Springs, Paso Robles
Medium garnet hue. Herbal aromas of cherry, treacle and cedar. Warm flavors of minerals, tar and coffee place the fruit firmly in the background. Lots of oak char in the finish. $26
90 Peachy Canyon, 2003 Zinfandel
Snow Vineyard, Paso Robles
Unfiltered garnet hue. Dusty, reserved aromas of cherry and cedar. Rich, expressive flavors of roasted plum, pencil, tar and espresso. Long, dry finish concludes on a mocha note. $26
90 Peachy Canyon, 2003 Zinfandel
Westside, Paso Robles
Deep red hue. Earthy, roasted scents of plum, cedar and smoke. Big, mineral-laced flavors of blackberry and tar. Baker's chocolate lifts the close. $19
92 Quivira, 2002 Zinfandel
Wine Creek Ranch, Dry Creek Valley
Reflective purple hue. Shy nose opens to a wave of cherry, mint and vanilla extract. Polished black cherry flavors display youthful zing. Spicy, tart close. $30
92 Quivira, 2003 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Vibrant garnet hue. Uplifting menthol aromas with black cherry, peppermint and evergreen notes. Forward flavors of plum, cherry and a youthful, peppery tartness. Long, fresh finish. $20
92 Rancho Zabaco, 2003 Zinfandel
Chiotti Vineyard, Dry Creek Valley
Medium garnet hue. Perfumed aromas of red berries, cherry and integrated wood notes. Lively, balanced flavors of cherry, plum, smoke and oak. $28
91 Rancho Zabaco, 2003 Toreador Zinfandel
Monte Rosso Vineyard, Sonoma County
Purple-black hue. Initial black pepper and spice notes yield to scents of blackberry and blueberry. Modestly sweet flavors of plum, blackberry, allspice and cinnamon. Smooth close. $50
88 Trentadue, 2002 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Purple hue. Integrated aromas of cherry, plum, charred oak and clove. Hearty flavors of crisp cherry, minerals and espresso. Racy finish. $18
87 Z52, 2002 Old Vine Zinfandel
Agnes' Vineyard, Lodi
Cloudy red hue. Pungent and earthy with a note of ripe plum in the nose. Sweet-tart fruit flavors with a vanillin oak accent. Drinking nicely right now. $16
86 Z52, 2003 Old Vine Zinfandel
Clockspring Vineyards, Amador County
Mixed aromas of pine, chocolate and pepper. Ripe cherry flavors with a note of mocha and oak. Earth and wood impressions punctuate the finish. $20
85 Chatom Vineyards, 2002 Zinfandel
Calaveras County - $16
85 ForestVille, 2003 Zinfandel
California - $6
85 Rockledge Vineyards, 2002 Zinfandel
Napa Valley - $18
Oregon
Whites
86 Argyle, 2003 Chardonnay
Willamette Valley
Pale gold hue. Toasted oak, ginger and honeydew melon aromas. Grapefruit and butterscotch flavors have crisp acidity. Youthful finish. $12
86 Ponzi Vineyards, 2004 Pinot Gris
Willamette Valley
Viscous straw hue. Pear and cantaloupe aromas. Clean, fresh flavors of peach, pear and minerals. Light, dry close. $17
87 Sokol Blosser, 2003 Pinot Gris
Dundee Hills
Burnished gold hue. Orange peel and nutmeg aromas. Ripe mango and apricot flavors with a cleansing acidic backbone. Dry finish. $21
Pinot Noir
88 Argyle, 2002 Nuthouse Pinot Noir
Willamette Valley
Deep ruby hue. Big aromas of black currant jam, tar and charred oak. Dry flavors of plum, black coffee and tobacco are a tad ungenerous. Peppery close. $19
91 Argyle, 2003 Pinot Noir
Reserve, Willamette Valley
Blackish-garnet hue. Forward aromas of black cherry, vanilla, cola and new oak. Spicy and sweet with black cherry and licorice flavors. A big Pinot packed with fruit, though it may be a little too muscular for some. $28
88 Cooper Mountain Vineyards, 2003 Pinot Noir
Reserve, Willamette Valley
Ruby hue. Perfumed scents of ripe red berries, underbrush, cinnamon and tobacco. Tingly acidity delivers flavors of strawberry and black pepper. Raspy finish. $18
87 King Estate, 2002 Pinot Noir
Oregon
Medium garnet hue. Brambly aromas of roasted plum and pencil. Flavors of raspberry, espresso bean and lots of cedar. Quite drying in the close. $24
90 Sokol Blosser, 2002 Pinot Noir
Dundee Hills
Medium cherry hue. Pungent aromas of red fruit, forest floor and a lightening mocha note. Bold flavors of raspberry, cedar and a hint of vanilla have a smooth texture. Tight close. $26
90 Willamette Valley Vineyards, 2004 Pinot Noir
Whole Cluster Fermented, Oregon
Pale garnet hue. A delicate bouquet emitting cherry, cedar and cinnamon scents. Light, dry structure with cherry, mineral and white pepper flavors. Good lick of cherry in the finish. $17 Willamette Valley Vineyards, 2002 Pinot Noir 88 Estate Vineyard, Oregon Ruby hue. Pungent forest floor aromas with a cherry note. Rich and thick with maple, cherry and cinnamon flavors. Cherry and oak in the close. $28
87 Willamette Valley Vineyards, 2002 Pinot Noir
Vintage Select, Oregon
Pale brick hue. Pencil lead, vanilla and cherry aromas. Tart cherry flavors with a smoky nuance running through the palate. Sweet finish with a light peppery accent. $19
Washington
Chardonnay
88 Chateau Ste. Michelle, 2003 Chardonnay
Columbia Valley
Bright gold hue. Toasted oak and pine nut aromas. Rather ripe peach and mango flavors that mesh nicely with the lingering toasted oak close. $13
90 Chateau Ste. Michelle, 2003 Chardonnay
Indian Wells Vineyard, Columbia Valley
Yellow-gold hue. Fresh aromas of orange marmalade and toasted oak. Rich flavors of peach nectar, sliced apple and new oak. Supple, oily texture with a nectar-like sweetness in the finish. $17
88 Chateau Ste. Michelle, 2003 Chardonnay
Canoe Ridge Estate, Columbia Valley
Light gold hue. Sweet aromas of vanilla, honey and toasted oak. Buttery texture with vanilla extract and peach flavors. Fresh, soft, ready-to-drink close. $20
90 Chateau Ste. Michelle, 2003 Chardonnay
Cold Creek Vineyard, Columbia Valley
Bright yellow hue. Upfront aromas of peach, apple and toasted oak with a whiff of cinnamon. Sweet apricot and peach flavors laced with new oak. Youthful astringency in the finish. $23
88 Chateau Ste. Michelle, 2003 Ethos Chardonnay
Columbia Valley
Gold hue. Campfire aromas with butternut and pecan accents. Tropical fruit flavors with a defined oakiness. Still somewhat youthful and restrained. Crisp peach and new oak cap the finish. $30
Cabernet Sauvignon
89 Pepper Bridge, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Seven Hills Vnyd Reserve, Walla Walla Valley
Black hue. Reserved aromas of fig, maple and cedar. Well-balanced if leanish flavors of blackberry, earth and coffee. Bittersweet chocolate in the close. $50
86 Snoqualmie, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Columbia Valley
Garnet hue with a faded rim. Earthy aromas of cedar and tobacco place the red currant decidedly in the background. Flavors of red fruit and coffee grounds. Wood notes in the finish. $23 Merlot
86 Pepper Bridge, 2002 Merlot
Walla Walla Valley
Crimson hue. Aromas of mixed berries, dried tobacco and earth. Dry flavors of plum and oak. A bitter note mars the finish. $45
87 Snoqualmie, 2002 Merlot
Reserve, Columbia Valley
Brick red hue. Herbal scents of plum and cedar are lifted by a perfume note. Soft flavors of red fruit, bell pepper and redwood. A citrusy tang in the close. $23
Argentina
Cabernet & Blends
88 Famiglia Bianchi, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
San Rafael, Mendoza
Blackish-purple hue. Fresh blueberry, plum and mint aromas. Solid core of black cherry flavors with a minty influence. Youthful, sweet finish. $18
90 Bodegas Norton , 2003 Privada
Lujan de Cuyo, Mendoza
Black hue. Smoky cherry aromas with a vanillin nuance. Ripe, exotic flavors of cherry, minerals and licorice. A well-priced blend of malbec, cabernet and merlot that possesses both power and finesse. $15
86 Novus, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Mendoza
Dense garnet hue. Cedar, tea and pine resin aromas. Soft red fruit flavors framed by fine grain tannins. Dry, crisp close with a note of citrus peel. $10
Malbec
87 Famiglia Bianchi, 2003 Malbec
San Rafael, Mendoza
Purple-violet hue. Dusty aromas of oak and tobacco eclipse subtler fruit scents. Concentrated flavors of jammy blackberry and sweet oak. Ripe, juicy finish. $18
88 Novus, 2003 Malbec
Mendoza
Light garnet hue. Floral scents of strawberry and cedar. Well-integrated flavors of sweet red berries, brown spice and oak. Dry close. $10
87 El Portillo, 2004 Malbec
Alto Valle de Uco, Mendoza
Deep crimson hue. Smoky aromas of earth and black pepper put the fruit in the background. Soft, spicy flavors of black plum and oak. Dry, peppery close. $9
88 Salentein, 2003 Malbec
Alto Valle de Uco, Mendoza
Black hue. Aromas of blueberry, chocolate and dusty earth. Velvety flavors of blackberry, mocha and cedar. A bell pepper note brings down the finish. $18
86 Santa Julia, 2004 Malbec
Mendoza
Medium ruby hue. Pungent aromas of cedar and bell pepper with a whiff of strawberry. Soft tannins and new oak frame roasted plum flavors. Sweet close. $8
88 Tamarí, 2003 Malbec
Reserva, Mendoza
Shiny purple hue. Rich aromas of plum, leather and smoke. Smooth flavors of blackberry, vanillin oak and mocha. Lusciously fruity finish. $10
86 Terrazas de los Andes, 2004 Malbec
Mendoza
Purple hue. Dusty aromas place the black fruit in the background. Soft flavors of blackberry and oak. Food-friendly close. $12
Chile
Chardonnay
87 Concha y Toro, 2004 Chardonnay
Casillero del Diablo, Casablanca Valley
Yellow-green hue. Rich aromas of lemon curd, banana and wet stone. Buttery flavors of pineapple, peach and lime. Clean, sweet, chewy finish. $9
89 Montes Alpha, 2004 Chardonnay
Special Cuvée, Casablanca Valley
Bright gold hue. Ripe aromas of banana, pineapple, butter and oak. Sweet, buttery flavors of grilled pineapple, peach and flan. Creamy, thick close. $23
87 Sincerity, 2004 Chardonnay
Organically Grown, Casablanca Valley
Yellow hue. Aromas of honeydew melon and pineapple are lifted by vanilla. Balanced flavors of mango, peach nectar and butter. Long close. $17 Sauvignon Blanc
86 Cousiño-Macul, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Maipo Valley
Bright gold hue. Ripe aromas of red apple, cut grass and bubblegum. Rich flavors of apricot, lime and clove. A sour note in the otherwise sweet close. $13
87 Picunche, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Casablanca Valley
Straw hue. Crisply varietal aromas of citrus, green chili and herbs. Light, fresh flavors of grapefruit and green chili with a pear note. Sweet-tart finish. $10
85 Errazuriz, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Estate, Casablanca Valley - $11
85 Montes, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Limited, Leyda Vnyd, Leyda Valley - $16
Cabernet & Blends
87 Casa Lapostolle, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Rapel Valley
Bright garnet hue. Fresh blueberry aromas with a note of pencil lead. Sweet cherry flavors with cinnamon and mocha accents. Tannic finish. $12
86 Errazuriz, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Max Reserva, Aconcagua Valley
Purple hue. Cherry and mocha aromas with a pungent, mushroom-like scent. Cherry flavors with drying wood tannins. Oak and mint in the close. $19
87 Errazuriz, 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon
Estate, Aconcagua Valley
Garnet hue. Cherry, redwood and vanilla aromas with a medicinal note. Dry cherry flavors with chalk and clove accents. Sweet, creamy finish. $11
88 Miguel Torres, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Old Vines, Manso de Velasco, Curicó
Bright garnet hue. Spicy aromas of cherry, cedar, evergreen and black pepper. Strawberry and cherry flavors mix with mocha and mint. Cherry close. $30
86 Montes, 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon
Oak Aged, Reserve, Colchagua Valley
Vibrant ruby hue. Pungent cherry, blueberry and oak aromas. Easy drinking with accessible plum and cherry flavors. Round finish. $10
88 Montes Alpha, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Apalta Vineyard, Colchagua Valley
Deep garnet hue. Forward aromas of eucalyptus, cherry and oak. Tart cherry flavors spiked with cedar. Spicy oak in the finish; however, the fruit holds on. $15
93 Montes , 2003 Alpha M
Alpalta Single Estate, Santa Cruz
Black garnet hue. Heady aromas of mint, new oak and blueberry. Layers of cherry and blueberry, couple with polished oak and a lingering, defined sweetness on the palate. An engaging "icon" wine. $75
87 El Portillo, 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon
Alto Valle de Uco, Mendoza
Crimson hue. Warm aromas of blackberry syrup and vanilla. Tangy flavors of spicy cherry and copious wood. Finishes a bit hot. $9
87 Salentein, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Alto Valle de Uco, Mendoza
Medium garnet hue. Sweet aromas of raspberry, brown spice and sawdust. Dry, tart flavors of cherry and vanillin oak. Warm close. $18
88 Santa Ema, 2001 Catalina
Cachapoal Valley
Pungent cherry aromas with a whiff of clove. Crisp flavors of cherry, licorice and oak finish on a spicy, bell pepper note. $27
84 Araucano, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Colchagua Valley - $10
85 Concha y Toro, 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon
Casillero del Diablo, Central Valley - $9
Merlot
86 Concha y Toro, 2004 Merlot
Casillero del Diablo, Central Valley
Black hue with a fuchsia rim. Muted scents of black fruit and earth. Spicy flavors of blackberry, forest floor and bell pepper. Warm finish. $9
88 Concha y Toro, 2003 Merlot
Marques de Casa Concha, Peumo
Dense garnet hue. Quite herbal aromas of black fruit, oak char and espresso. Soft, concentrated flavors of blackberry and graphite. Vanillin oak lightens the finish. $16
86 Montes Alpha, 2003 Merlot
Apalta Vineyard, Colchagua Valley
Shimmering garnet hue. Reserved, woodsy plum aromas. Flavors of plum, coffee, bell pepper and earth. Dry close. $15
87 Montes, 2004 Merlot
Reserve, Special Cuvée, Colchagua Valley
Ruby-black hue. Deep aromas of plum and smoke. Ample black fruit and menthol flavors have an herbal edge. Boysenberry in the close. $10
85 Viña Tarapaca, 2001 Merlot
Gran Reserva, Maipo Valley - $17
Other Reds
95 Montes, 2003 Folly Syrah
Alpata Vineyard, Apalta Valley
An intense, purple-to-the-rim hue. Uplifting aromas of plum, cherry, blueberry, sage and vanilla. Laden with supple black fruit flavors, rustic tannins and a distinct minerality throughout. Excellent length; keeps improving in the glass. $75
87 Montes, 2004 Malbec
Reserve, Colchagua Valley
Fuchsia hue. Peppery aromas of plum and dust. Balanced flavors of black fruit, earth and sweetened coffee. Lively close. $10
94 Montes, 2003 Purple Angel Carmenère
Colchagua Valley
A barrel sample tasted last June was impressive for its early integration; the finished version, made with 8% petit verdot, is easily the best Carmenère reviewed to date. An India-ink hue paints the glass. Full aromas of toasted oak, clove, cherry and plum. Mouth-coating flavors of spicy plum and cherry laced with youthful, fine grain tannins and a kindred earthiness. A menthol edge in the close leaves the mouth humming. $50
Global Rosés
88 Clos LaChance, 2004 Rosé
Central Coast
Pale fuchsia hue. Reserved, if perfumed, scents of strawberry and rhubarb. Balanced flavors of cranberry and apple. Crisp finish. $14
87 Eberle, 2004 Syrah Rosé
Paso Robles
Light rhubarb hue. New oak dominates aromas of cherry and dust. Big, smoky flavors of ripe cherry and cranberry. Long, lively close. $14
87 Folie à Deux, 2004 Ménage à Trois Rosé
California
Pale cherry hue. Bold aromas of maraschino cherry and candied orange peel. Medium sweet cherry juice flavors. Easy-drinking close. $12
86 Forest Glen, 2004 White Merlot
California
Fuchsia hue. Lively scents of fresh-picked red berries. Juicy, sweet-tart cherry flavors. Quaffable close. $10
87 Frog's Leap, 2004 Pink
La Grenouille Rouganté, Napa Valley
Radish-red hue. Candied aromas of cherry cola and strawberry. Lively cranberry and strawberry flavors. Moist tobacco highlights the finish. $10
89 Handley, 2004 Pinot Noir Rosé
Anderson Valley
Cranberry hue. Earthy aromas of black cherry and vanilla. Fresh flavors of sour cherry, strawberry and cedar. Intense sweet-and-sour close. $16
87 Hook & Ladder, 2003 White Zinfandel
Russian River Valley
Orange-copper hue. A mix of apricot, nutmeg and apple juice aromas. Sweet apple and cinnamon flavors with a note of citrus peel in the finish. $8
89 Jaboulet, 2004 Parallèle 45 Rosé
Côtes-du-Rhône, France
Rhubarb hue. Clean, floral strawberry aromas. Dry, balanced flavors of red berries and orange zest. Closes with a fruity flourish. $10
86 Pascal Jolivet, 2004 Attitude Rosé-Pinot Noir
Loire Valley, France
Pale salmon hue. Aromas of candy apple and burnt sugar. Tart raspberry flavors have a spritzy texture. Appetite-whetting finish. $16
87 Pink Knot, 2005 Rosé
McClaren Vale, Australia
Pink-orange hue. Luscious aromas of strawberry and rhubarb. Pleasingly dry cherry flavors have a cedar nuance. Orange zest in the finish. $12
89 Red Bicyclette, 2004 Rosé
Vin de Pays d'Oc, France
Reddish-orange hue. Seamlessly integrated aromas of cherry blossom, gravel and a hint of brown spice. Refreshing flavors of strawberry and apple. Lingering, tart close. $10
89 Robert Hall, 2004 Rosé de Robles
Paso Robles
Dark ruby hue. Integrated nose of ripe strawberry, pencil and peppermint. Weighty flavors of cherry and earth. Dry, fruity close. $14
86 Sanford, 2004 Pinot Noir-Vin Gris
Santa Rita Hills, Santa Barbara County
Medium copper hue. Reserved scents of citrus and flowers. Balanced flavors of raspberry and apricot. Dry finish. $13
88 Solo Rosa, 2004 Rosé
California
Light candy apple red hue. Aromas of cherry and orange have an herbal nuance. Tangy flavors of rhubarb and strawberry are quite clean and focused. Sweet-tart finish. $15
88 Tortoise Creek, 2004 Rosé d'Une Nuit
Vin de Pays d'Oc, France
Bright penny hue. Fresh cranberry and strawberry aromas. Crisp cranberry and tart apricot flavors. Light, dry close. $9
86 Vina Robles, 2004 Roseum Syrah
Paso Robles
Light cranberry hue. Gamy aromas of apricot and earth. Meaty flavors of cherry and brown spices. Fruit slowly emerges in the close. $13
84 Banrock Station, 2004 White Shiraz
South Eastern Australia - $7
85 El Coto, 2004 Rosé
Rioja, Spain - $10
85 Jean-Luc Colombo, 2004 Rosé de Côte Bleue
Coteaux d'Aix, France - $10
84 The Little Penguin, 2005 White Shiraz
South Eastern Australia - $8
84 Domaine de Nizas, 2004 Rosé
Coteaux du Languedoc, France - $16
West Coast Case
89 Belle Glos, 2003 Pinot Noir
Clark & Telephone Vnyd, Santa Maria Vly
Produced entirely from the venerable Martini clone on 33-year-old vines, it offers forward, spicy aromas of red berries and a subtle green herb note with hints of smoke and fresh, loamy earth. Very smooth, round and luscious on the palate with medium tannins and crisp acidity delivering rich, deep flavors of red fruit tinged with harmonious green herbs. $38/2,800 cases
91 Canihan Family Vnyd, 2003 Pinot Noir
Irrational Exuberance, Carneros/Sonoma Vly
Forward, very fragrant nose of allspice, ripe, freshly crushed raspberry, subdued forest floor, and a whiff of Earl Grey tea accented by lavender. Silky smooth and elegant with medium tannins, the flavors replicate the nose and are nicely concentrated; long, smooth finish. $30/25 cases
92 Copain, 2003 Pinot Noir
Kiser Vineyard, Anderson Valley
From the vineyard in the valley closest to the ocean, beyond which grapes can't be cultivated. Distinctive nose of red meat, black raspberry-strawberry fruit with hints of green herbs, faint smokiness and a subtle vanilla note, which is echoed on the palate of this medium-full-bodied, classy Pinot. Loaded with extracted, concentrated fruit that needs at least a year in bottle to shine even more. $40/50 cases
90 Goldeneye, 2002 Pinot Noir
Anderson Valley
Rich, attractive aromas of black raspberry, black cherry and plum mingle with subtle green herbs, smoked bacon and toasted anise seed. Plush and juicy with medium tannins, offering copious black fruit streaked with strawberry and red cherry, this well-crafted Pinot is seamless and harmoniously balanced, delivering boldness and balance. $52/2,500 cases
92 Lazy Creek, 2003 Pinot Noir
Reserve, Anderson Valley
Initially subdued nose that opens with airing to show black raspberry, lots of warm brown spice and dried lavender. Silky and luscious, this reserve is brimming with liqueur-like black fruit that's nicely extracted; a powerful expression of Pinot, yet still well behaved. $70/100 cases
90 Londer, 2003 Pinot Noir
Parabol, Anderson Valley
Enticing, fragrant scents of Asian spice, red cherry-red currant fruit and a touch of vanilla. Velvety smooth with supple, medium-full tannins, offering copious, rich red fruit flavors accented by sour cherry. A deeply flavored Pinot. $48/290 cases
91 Longoria, 2003 Pinot Noir
Bien Nacido Vineyard, Santa Maria Valley
Forward, slightly smoky nose of freshly crushed raspberry, allspice, loamy earth and black licorice. Harmonious with medium tannins and perky acidity, delivering deep, nicely concentrated flavors that replicate the nose; long, spice-tinged close. $42/340 cases
92 Longoria, 2003 Pinot Noir
Fe Ciega Vineyard, Santa Rita Hills
Initial scents of white pepper and dried herbs are soon joined by freshly crushed strawberry and red plum compote tinged with subtle smokiness and nutmeg. Silky smooth with firm, Santa Rita Hills acidity and supple tannins, offering a tasty interplay of succulent strawberry, white pepper and minerality. $42/340 cases
91 MacPhail, 2003 Pinot Noir
Toulouse Vineyard, Anderson Valley
Attractive, upfront aromas of wild strawberry and cassis, accented by forest floor earthiness and vanilla bean. Ultraplush and luscious, this powerful, masculine-style Pinot is loaded with extracted, concentrated fruit, ripe, medium tannins and fairly evident oak. Jim MacPhail's exuberant wine is exciting to drink now, but deserves cellaring to bring more nuance to its persona. $35/340 cases
90 Navarro, 2003 Pinot Noir
Deep End Blend, Anderson Valley
Shy nose of freshly crushed wild strawberry dusted with white pepper and accented by violets. Plush and sensuous in the mouth and loaded with sweet strawberry-cranberry flavors tinged with red currant, this complex, expressive Pinot has mouthwatering acidity and ripe, medium-full tannins. Finishes with a subtle note of smoked meat. (March 2006 release) $42/1,341 cases
88 TAZ, 2003 Pinot Noir
Cuyama River, Santa Maria Valley
Attractive scents of subtle green herbs, ripe raspberry-red cherry fruit and cinnamon spice. Smooth, round and juicy in the mouth with fine, supple tannins and lovely red fruit flavors that are more delicate than generous and tinged with spice that lingers in the close. An elegant expression of the variety. $28/500 cases
90 Woodenhead Vintners, 2003 Pinot Noir
Anderson Valley
Exotic scents of sandalwood-tinged black fruit and red currant are replicated on the palate of this plush, super smooth Pinot. Flavors of red raspberry and strawberry give the wine a kirsch-like viscosity with complex notes of sour cherry and pomegranate with a hint of green tea; medium tannins and excellent balance. $42/310 cases
- Steve Pitcher
About the BuyLine Panel: More than 100 wines are reviewed in every issue of Wine News. All wines are tasted double-blind and each entry is evaluated and scored based upon individual merit. Wines that score above 70 points are recommended in the BuyLine. Tasting and interpreting wine is a purely subjective exercise; all scores and accompanying tasting notes represent the collective opinions of our panel.
Wine Samples: Send samples for review with retail price affixed to:
Wine News BuyLine Tasting Panel
1501 Venera Avenue, Suite 320
Coral Gables, FL 33146
Telephone: 305.740.7170
The Panel: Maurice Adams, specialty food and wine merchant; Lyn Farmer, senior staff columnist; Abraham Horowitz, BuyLine panelist; Tom E. Smith, publisher; John Stroker, BuyLine panelist; Fred Tasker, Miami Herald wine critic; Todd M. Wernstrom, executive editor.
Scoring: Tasting notes reflect the panel's collective impressions; scores are averaged and represent the panel's mean. Wines possessing certain criteria will be singled out for special recognition:
Taster's Choice: Wines which display outstanding quality, character and potential.
Best Value Wines of exceptional quality which sell at a moderate price.
Stemware: Riedel Ouverture tasting glasses.
Pricing: Prices vary from state to state. Retail prices listed are approximate.
