Wine Reviews from The Wine News
tasters' choice selections
94 Caymus Vineyard, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Special Selection, Napa Valley
Solid garnet hue to the rim. Scents of campfire, cherry and sage with a minty note. A silky textured wine with soft tannins nicely meshed with flavors of plum, maple and mineral. Displays remarkable balance and purity of fruit, and will surprise the tempted by how well it is drinking right now. $136 / 8,800 cases
93 EOS Estate, 2003 Cupa Grandis Chardonnay
Brothers Ranch Vineyard, Paso Robles
Burnished gold hue. A full bouquet of apple juice, honey, brown sugar and cantaloupe. Round and supple with layers of tropical fruit flavors laced with brown spices. Honey- and oak-kissed close. $40
93 Trentadue Winery, 2002 La Storia Zinfandel
Alexander Valley
Brooding, viscous purple hue. Uplifting plum, cherry and alcohol aromas with a whiff of pencil and cedar. Layers of plum and blueberry flavors with a complementing mineral nuance that adds depth and structure while driving the fruit-laden finish. $28
best value selections
90 Blackstone Winery, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Sonoma County
Dense garnet hue with a ruby rim. Intense, minerally, peppery aromas of mixed berries and mocha. Chalky texture frames nervy flavors of blackberry, orange and flint. Warm, citrusy close. $16 / 6,100 cases
87 Canyon Road, 2003 Merlot
California
Saturated purple hue. Very dusty aromas of cola, mint and maple. Minerally flavors of raspberry, cherry liqueur and oak with a mushroom note. A pleasant mix of fruit and earth in the finish. $9
87 Kendall-Jackson, 2002 Zinfandel
California
Deep brick hue with a violet rim. Uplifting aromas of plum, tobacco and new oak. Lean, racy, balanced flavors of black fruit, licorice and toasted oak. Spicy close. $12
publisher's pick
93 Provenance, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Rutherford, Napa Valley
Intense black-garnet hue. Fresh bouquet of blueberry jam, vanilla, coffee and charred oak. Excellent weight with lush blueberry flavors laced with sweet wood tannins. Fruit-driven finish shows power and finesse. $35 / 16,636 cases
California
Chardonnay
88 Alderbrook, 2003 Chardonnay
Russian River Valley
Bright gold hue. Aromas of banana, apricot, flowers and honey. Flavors of pear and charred oak are less ripe than suggested by the nose. Grapy finish. $17
87 Beaulieu Vineyard, 2003 Chardonnay
Carneros
Light yellow hue. Ripe tropical aromas of mango and pineapple. Soft, creamy flavors of lemon and apple. Lingering peach notes in the close. $19 - AH
89 Bernardus, 2003 Chardonnay
Monterey County
Yellow hue. Ripe peach aromas with a whiff of banana. Focused pineapple and apricot flavors have a youthful bite. Dry, well-oaked finish. $20
86 Clos du Val, 2003 Chardonnay
Carneros
Gold hue. Fresh aromas of pineapple and citrus peel. Tart and steely with mineral and citrus flavors. Oak surfaces in the somewhat tight, youthful close. $21
87 EOS Estate, 2003 Chardonnay
Reserve, Paso Robles
Sharp gold hue. Lively aromas of sliced apple, vanilla and lanolin. Crisp structure imparts apple, peach and oak flavors. Racy finish. $20
88 Forest Glen, 2002 Chardonnay
Reserve, Sonoma County
White gold hue. Nose emits ripe melon, pear and apple aromas. Pineapple and honeydew flavors have an edgy bite of citrus. Rather sweet finish. $22
91 Franciscan Oakville Estate, 2002 Cuvée Sauvage
Wild Yeast, Carneros, Napa Valley
Bright yellow hue. Attractive butterscotch and caramel aromas. Grilled pineapple, nutmeg and vanilla flavors. Lasting, supple close with nicely melded charred oak and honey notes. $33
88 Frank Family Vineyards, 2003 Chardonnay
Napa Valley
Gold hue with a green tint. Ripe aromas of pineapple and brown spice. Lively flavors of peach, apricot and sliced apple. Tart finish. $29
90 Geyser Peak Winery, 2003 Chardonnay
Russian River Valley
Deep gold hue. Honeyed flavors of peach, pineapple, butter and paraffin. Rich, well-balanced flavors of baked pineapple and oak. Long, razor-sharp close. $19
87 Gloria Ferrer, 2002 Chardonnay
Carneros
Pale straw hue. Fresh scents of oak, clove and lime peel. Racy and tart with citrus rind and mineral flavors. Tart finish shows bracing acidity. $18
88 Hook & Ladder, 2003 Chardonnay
Russian River Valley
Burnished gold hue. Well-integrated aromas of apple, butter and toasted oak. Flavors of baked apple and wood spice are ripe without being overdone. Clean, lively close. $16
90 Morgan, 2003 Chardonnay
Monterey
Deep gold hue. Subtle scents of white fruit, oak and a hint of burnt sugar. Fresh flavors of mango, peach and oak are quite tangy and mouth-filling. Traces of butter in the lingering finish. $20
90 Napa Cellars, 2003 Chardonnay
Napa Valley
Clear straw hue. Upfront toasted oak aromas with bright peach and pencil shaving notes. Creamy texture with plenty of ripe peach flavors balanced nicely by toasted oak. Fruit-driven close. $19
87 St. Clement, 2003 Chardonnay
Carneros, Napa Valley
Yellow hue. Buttery, well-oaked aromas with grilled pineapple notes. Supple peach and pineapple flavors laced with new oak. Sweet, nectar-like finish. $16
87 Stephen Ross, 2003 Chardonnay
Edna Valley
White gold hue. Light citrus and floral scents. Sweet, toasty flavors of peach and cream show a metallic bite. Sweetness prevails in the finish. $20
87 Toasted Head, 2003 Chardonnay
Russian River Valley
Dense gold hue. Layered aromas of pineapple, honey and butter. Waxy flavors of banana peel and oak. Quiet close. $17
92 ZD, 2003 Chardonnay
California
Bright yellow-gold hue. Forward aromas of pineapple, cedar, pencil, clove and a cured ham sweetness. Juicy peach, oak and cinnamon flavors. Lengthy finish has a nectar-like sweetness and a pinch of nutmeg. $30
85 EOS Estate, 2003 Chardonnay
Paso Robles
- $12
83 Pepi, 2004 Chardonnay
California
- $9
Sauvignon Blanc
87 Canyon Road, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
California
Straw yellow hue. True varietal scents of lime, wet slate and chili pepper. Flavors of lime and bell pepper. Tart citrus envelopes the finish. $8
86 Cypress Vineyards, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
California
White gold hue. Shy scents of chili pepper and gravel. More pronounced flavors of citrus and bell pepper. Clean close. $10
87 Francis Coppola, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Yellow Label, Diamond Collection, Napa Vly
Pale gold hue. Forward aromas of pink grapefruit, peach and bell pepper. Balanced flavors of lime and chili pepper. Persistent citrus in the close. $16
87 Gainey, 2003 Sauvignon Blanc
Limited Selection, Santa Ynez Valley
Light gold hue. Sweetly floral aromas of ripe citrus and honeydew melon. Soft flavors of peach pit and butter. Long, apple-studded finish. $20
86 Hanna, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Russian River Valley, Sonoma County
Pale yellow hue. Subtle scents of lime, grapefruit and minerals. Forceful flavors of apple and citrus peel. Lime-soaked close. $17
86 Markham, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Napa Valley
Light yellow hue. Sweet aromas of peach and white flowers. Soft body frames flavors of ripe apple and wood spice. Clean finish. $14
85 Camelot, 2003 Sauvignon Blanc
California
- $7
85 ForestVille, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
California
- $6
85 Handley, 2003 Sauvignon Blanc
Handley Vineyard, Dry Creek Valley
- $12
85 Huntington, 2004 Sauvignon Blanc
Earthquake, Sonoma County
- $12
84 Morgan, 2003 Sauvignon Blanc
Monterey
- $14
85 Mount St. Helena, 2003 Sauvignon Blanc
Napa Valley
- $16
Cabernet & Blends
89 Altamura, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Black hue with a fuchsia tint. Charred aromas of black cherry, chestnut, barnyard and cream soda. Intense, silky flavors of blueberry, fig, tar and graphite. Layered close features chocolate. $60
86 Astrale e Terra, 2001 Arcturus
Napa Valley
Deep crimson hue. Aromas of plum, tar and just-cut lumber. Flavors of raspberry and mocha are just a bit thin. Soft finish. $39
90 Beaulieu Vineyard, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Rutherford, Napa Valley
Inky hue with a garnet rim. Attractive bouquet of plum, mint and pencil shavings. Youthful black cherry and oak flavors with rough-hewn tannins. Closes on a minty note; a promising wine that needs time to soften. $25
86 Beaulieu Vineyard, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Bright garnet hue. Blueberry aromas with tobacco and charred oak accents. Soft structure with red fruit, tea and oak flavors. Finishes dry and earthy. $17
90 Beaulieu Vineyard, 2001 Tapestry
Napa Valley
Dark crimson hue. Complex aromas of smoke and black cherry with secondary notes of cedar and mint. Juicy flavors of wild cherry and raspberry framed by fine grain tannins. A touch of oak and cedar in the wild cherry-driven close. $40 - AH
87 Bennett-Lane, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Purple hue with a feathered garnet rim. Pungent charred oak scents with a clove note. Cherry and mocha flavors with a lick of vanilla. Crisp finish. $45
86 Bennett-Lane, 2002 Maximus
Napa Valley
Cloudy garnet hue. Stewed cherry, leather and evergreen aromas. Youthful and tannic with cherry and chocolate flavors. Mineral-laden close. $28
92 Benziger, 2002 Tribute
Sonoma Mountain
Unfiltered garnet hue. Powerful aromas of black cherry, mint, cedar chest and orange rind. Edgy flavors of plum, cherry and baker's chocolate with rough-hewn tannins marking finish. This is a wine with power and grip that is presently showing its youthfulness; needs time to turn the corner. $65
86 Big Horn Cellars, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Brick red hue. Waxy aromas of peppermint, black pepper and pine resin. Spicy flavors of blackberry and oak. Minerally close. $30
87 Big Horn Cellars, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Coombsville Vineyard, Napa Valley
Inky black hue. Reserved scents of black fruit, cigar smoke and mint. Lean, racy flavors of blackberry, baker's chocolate and smoke. Gritty close. $40
88 Cain Vineyard & Winery, 2001 Cain Concept
Napa Valley
Bright ruby hue. Pungent aromas of cherry syrup, menthol and barrel. Flavors of cherry, rhubarb, pencil and oak char. Surprisingly silky finish. $46
91 Chappellet, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Dense crimson hue. Reserved scents of blueberry, dust and graphite. Layered, silky smooth flavors of plum, blackberry, bittersweet chocolate and vanillin oak. Focused, earthy close. $44
92 Cliff Lede, 2002 Claret
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Vibrant garnet hue. Fresh scents of cherry, leather and caramel. Intense, dusty flavors of cherry, licorice and clove. Youthful finish with peppery tannins and plenty of Stags Leap fruit for the long haul. $32
87 Cliff Lede, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Purple hue to the rim. Forward aromas of alcohol, cherry and resin. Stewed cherry flavors and woody tannins. Mocha and cedar punctuate the close. $50
90 Chateau Souverain, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Winemaker's Reserve, Alexander Valley
Black-garnet hue. Rich aromas of boysenberry, brown sugar, smoke and cedar. Complex mix of rhubarb, orange juice, mint and tobacco flavors. A mineral note marks the close. $40
90 Chimney Rock, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Medium crimson hue. Reserved scents of briary raspberry and eucalyptus. Dense flavors of cherry, tar, pencil and tobacco. Finish marked by sweet fruit. $49
88 Clos du Val, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Intense ruby hue. Dusty scents of plum, date, just-cut lumber and clove. Bold flavors of boysenberry, cherry and cedar spiked by citrusy acidity. Youthful finish. $28
92 Clos Pegase, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Hommage, Napa Valley
Ruby-black hue. Exotic, floral aromas of black plum, cherry, iodine, cedar and root beer. Weighty flavors of cherry, bittersweet chocolate, smoke and tobacco. Long, intense, earthy finish packs plenty of fruit. $75
92 Fisher Vineyards, 2002 Cameron
Napa Valley
Dense black-garnet hue. Heady bouquet of cherry, leather, sandalwood and vanilla. Bright flavors of cherry, plum, black earth and a note of tobacco. Lengthy close driven by intense fruit. $50
87 Forest Glen, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Sonoma County
Garnet hue. Aromas of orange peel, redwood and cinnamon. Vibrant and crisp with lively red fruit and mineral flavors. Spicy, acidic finish. $34
88 Franciscan Oakville Estate, 2001 Magnificat
Napa Valley
Unfiltered garnet hue. Rich aromas of blackberry, mocha, cinnamon and oak char. Lively flavors of cherry, cranberry, chalk and bramble. Dry, leathery close. $40
88 Frank Family Vnyds, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Dense crimson hue. Aggressive blueberry, cedar, mint and pencil aromas. Blueberry and black cherry flavors wrapped in tooth-sticking tannins. Drying finish shows promise. $35
90 Frank Family Vnyds, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Rutherford, Napa Valley
Deep garnet hue. Heady aromas of plum, campfire, coffee and mocha. Chalky cherry flavors with oak char notes and peppery tannins. This a fruit-driven wine that needs time for the wood to back off. $65
89 Frog's Leap, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Ruby-black hue. Big, smoky aromas of mixed berries, cherry, new oak and a pretty juniper note. Fresh, vibrant flavors of red cherry, strawberry, wet stone and chocolate. Long, crisp finish. $39
88 Gary Farrell, 2001 Encounter
Sonoma County
Deep crimson hue. Dusty aromas of plum, cedar and shoe polish. Sweet-tart flavors of cranberry, cherry, musty oak and chocolate. Intense close. $60
91 Geyser Peak Winery, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Kuimelis Vineyard, Alexander Valley
Bright garnet hue. Ripe aromas of cherry, violets and chocolate with a lingering menthol note. Mouth-coating black cherry flavors with combed tannins. This is a charming, accessible wine with plump fruit and soft tannins in the finish. $42
91 Geyser Peak Winery, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Alexander Valley
Inky black hue. Forward aromas of plum, pencil, new oak, tobacco and mocha. Full-bodied flavors of blueberry, coffee, minerals and clove. Dry close features coffee notes. $46
92 Geyser Peak Winery, 2001 Reserve Alexandre
Alexander Valley
Black-purple hue. Ripe, perfumed scents of blackberry, cherry, vanilla and bittersweet chocolate. Concentrated, supple, velvety flavors of blackberry, cassis, walnut and dark chocolate. Lengthy close shows chocolate and minerals. $49
89 Girard, 2001 Red Wine
Napa Valley
Crimson-black hue. Heady, almost medicinal aromas of raspberry, candied fruit, dried tobacco and root beer. Earthy flavors of strawberry jam, espresso and wood spice. Tar appears in the close. $40
88 Hahn, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Central Coast
Reddish-black hue. Aromas of plum, new oak, pencil and an interesting red meat note. Chalky, concentrated flavors of mixed berries and bittersweet chocolate. Sweetens up in the close. $14
88 Hahn, 2003 Meritage
Central Coast
Fuchsia-garnet hue. Warm, leathery aromas of rhubarb, dust and cedar. Soft flavors of roasted black fruit and violets. Spiced fruit accents the finish. $20
91 Hartwell Vnyds, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Deep crimson hue. Well-integrated aromas of plum, black cherry, coffee bean and a new oak note. Supple flavors of spicy cherry, maple, coffee and dark chocolate reveal just a hint of alcoholic sting. Brown sugar in the opulent finish. $115
90 Hess Collection, 2002 Mountain Cuvée
Mount Veeder-Napa Valley
Crimson-black hue. Dusty aromas of raspberry, citrus peel and wood notes. Layered flavors of blackberry, plum, minerals and tar are more generous than suggested by the nose. Long close lifted by a vanilla nuance. $35
87 Hook & Ladder, 2003 The Tillerman
Estate Bottled, Russian River Valley
Purple-garnet hue. Big aromas of fig, bell pepper, cedar and Worcestershire sauce. Lean flavors of plum, minerals and earth. Semisweet chocolate in the pleasing finish. $16
87 J. Lohr, 2000 Cabernet Sauvignon
Hilltop Vineyard, Paso Robles
Medium garnet hue. Sweet aromas of blackberry, brown sugar and German chocolate cake frosting. Balanced flavors of black fruit, cedar and earth. Drying finish. $32
89 J. Lohr, 2000 Cuvée St. E
Paso Robles
Deep ruby hue. Nicely meshed aromas of stewed plum, maple, sweet smoke and an herbal note. Soft flavors of blackberry, anise and wood spice have flattering acidity. Lingering close is quite spicy. $50
90 J. Lohr, 2000 Cuvée POM
Paso Robles
Medium garnet hue with a faded rim. Lean aromas of cassis, dust and forest floor. Youthful flavors of blackberry, sweet oak and espresso. Zesty, vanilla-tinged finish. $50
91 J. Lohr, 2000 Cuvée PAU
Paso Robles
Medium ruby hue. Sweet, brambly aromas of boysenberry, tobacco and an herbal note. Slow-to-open flavors of mixed berries, leather and cedar. Long, layered close shows ample fruit and a touch of wood. $50
88 Léal Estate, 2001 Carnavál Meritage
San Benito
Dense crimson hue. New oak somewhat masks aromas of plum, rhubarb and lanolin. Flavors of cherry, sweet tobacco and cedar. Zesty close. $24
87 Léal Estate, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Unfiltered, San Benito
Garnet hue. Peppery red berry aromas but otherwise shy in the nose. Tangy flavors of blackberry and shoe polish. A bitter note in the finish. $24
91 Long Meadow Ranch, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Deep purple hue. Warm, generous aromas of plum, mint, tobacco and cedar. Concentrated though not ponderous flavors of blackberry, cherry, bittersweet chocolate, pencil and oak. Tight, youthful close. $55
90 Mettler Family Vnyds, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Lodi
Attractive garnet hue. Earthy scents of plum, blueberry and a vanillin note. Ripe black cherry, plum, tea and sweet tobacco flavors; a balanced, juicy Cabernet that's drinking nicely right now. $25
87 Mount St. Helena, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Black-garnet hue. Warm, earthy aromas of plum, wet stone and a bell pepper note. Flavors of smoke, minerals and espresso with black fruit highlights. New oak shows up in the close. $25
90 Piña Cellars, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Howell Mountain, Napa Valley
Medium garnet hue. Well-integrated aromas of mixed berries, black olive, clove and charred oak. Tightly packed flavors of plum, cherry, coffee bean and bittersweet chocolate. Intense, tarry finish. $54
89 Pine Ridge, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Oakville, Napa Valley
Bright ruby hue. Smoky aromas of prune, black olive, cedar and pencil. Concentrated, minerally flavors of blackberry, maple sugar and vanilla. Gutsy, earthy finish. $60
89 Raymond, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Napa
Reddish hue. Big aromas of black fruit, red meat, bacon fat and cedar. Bright flavors of plum, briar, redwood and earth. Somewhat woody close. $35
88 Raymond, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Bright garnet hue. Vibrant aromas of raspberry, cedar, vanilla and mint. Cherry and chocolate flavors with secondary mineral accents. Lively, crisp finish still shows its youthful side. $20
93 Regusci, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Viscous inky hue with a garnet rim. Ripe aromas of blueberry, plum and dark chocolate. Delicious front-row fruit, headlined by plum and mint, have a defined creaminess. Tannins and oak power-up the finish, however, there is a fistful of fruit to temper the wood. $48
86 Rodney Strong, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Sonoma County
Dense purple hue with a fuchsia rim. Upfront oak aromas followed by cherry, chocolate and pencil. Cherry and strawberry flavors. Oak-driven close needs time for the fruit to come forward. $19
87 Sebastiani, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Alexander Valley
Inky hue. Woodsy aromas coupled with coffee bean, pencil shavings and baker's chocolate notes. Plump cherry flavors have sandpaper tannins. Dry, chalky finish with obvious oak impressions. $28
91 Sebastiani, 2002 Secolo
Sonoma County
Intense purple hue. Fresh plum and blueberry aromas with notes of clove and vanilla. Plenty of plum and black cherry flavors laced with minerals. Drying and still somewhat youthful close with ample oak and promising fruit. $30
89 Sequoia Grove, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Rutherford, Napa Valley
Black-red hue. Sweet aromas of boysenberry, coconut, maple and a smoky nuance. Flavors of plum, cherry, mocha and espresso are nicely wrapped around an oak core. Plush close shows ripeness. $55
87 Simi, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Landslide Vineyard, Alexander Valley
Unfiltered garnet hue. Aromas of blackberry, cedar and dusty gravel have a bell pepper undertone. Spicy, briary cherry flavors are a touch hot. Warm, peppery finish. $33
86 Sterling, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
Vintner's Collection, Central Coast
Red hue. Woodsy aromas of plum, blueberry and vanilla. Dry cherry flavors with very fine tannins. Light, crisp close. $15
91 SummerWood, 2001 Sentio
Central Coast
Feathered garnet hue. Sprightly aromas of just-crushed berries, cherry, violets and brown spice. Very tangy flavors of ripe cherry, semisweet chocolate and tea have a creamy texture. Spicy, citrusy close. $50
88 Toasted Head, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Alexander Valley
Reddish-black hue. A bell pepper note marks aromas of rhubarb, dust and cedar. Smooth flavors of blackberry, espresso and pencil. Minerally finish. $20
90 Zahtila Vineyards, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Deep garnet hue. Floral scents of mixed berries, dust and minerals. Lean but very intense flavors of ripe blackberry, licorice and ample earth. Long, mineral-laced finish. $33
90 Zahtila Vineyards, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Beckstoffer Vnyd, Georges III, Rutherford
Purple-black hue. Uplifting aromas of plum, blueberry, cola and dust. Earthy, balanced flavors of plum, blackberry, wood spice and mint. Lots of wood in the otherwise dry close. $50
84 Canyon Road, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
California
- $9
85 Cypress Vineyards, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
California
- $10
85 Huntington, 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
California
- $12
85 Two Tone Farm, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
- $10
Merlot
87 Clos du Val, 2002 Merlot
Napa Valley
Deep ruby hue. Pleasing aromas of tart red fruit, tobacco, cedar and mocha. Sweet-tart flavors of cherry, rhubarb and oak offset by peppery tannins. Quite dry close. $25
86 Cypress, 2003 Merlot
California
Dense purple hue. Tart aromas of strawberry, briar and dust. Flavors of red berries and plum continue the tart theme. A metallic note marks the close. $10
87 Firestone Vineyard, 2002 Merlot
Santa Ynez Valley
Black-purple hue. Shy scents of cherry cola, dust and floral notes. Forward flavors of blackberry, cedar and new oak. Drying close shows lots of wood. $18
88 Gainey, 2002 Unfiltered Merlot
Limited Selection, Santa Ynez Valley
Black hue. Pungent aromas of just-cut pine, menthol and dust with the fruit in the background. Flavors of blackberry, cherry, mint and coffee are a good bit sweeter than suggested by the nose. Long finish. $35
90 Gainey, 2002 Merlot
Santa Ynez Valley
Deep crimson hue. Warm, brambly aromas of blackberry, black plum, smoke and bittersweet chocolate. Tangy flavors of blackberry, chocolate, chalk and new oak are very well integrated. A coffee bean note highlights the finish. $19
87 Hahn, 2003 Merlot
Monterey
Unfiltered crimson hue. Jammy aromas of brambly plum, cherry, resin and brown sugar. Concentrated flavors of strawberry, citrus peel and sweetened chocolate. Sweet-tart close. $14
89 Hanna, 2001 Merlot
Estate Grown, Sonoma County
Nearly black hue. Restrained aromas of red wood, minerals, mocha and mushroom with the fruit in the background. Opulent flavors of black fruit, coffee, brown sugar and chocolate. Soft finish. $26
88 Huntington, 2002 Merlot
California
Deep garnet hue. Cedary aromas of grape jam, blueberry, semisweet chocolate and smoke. Rich flavors of blueberry, hard candy, milk chocolate and vanillin oak. Generous, well-fruited close. $12
88 Raymond, 2002 Merlot
Reserve, Napa Valley
Crimson-black hue. Spicy aromas of plum, mixed berries, gravel and cedar. Sweet oak and coconut frame flavors of boysenberry, espresso and brown sugar. Maple marks the finish. $20
90 Rutherford Hill, 2002 Merlot
Napa Valley
Medium garnet hue. Earthy aromas of brambly raspberry, cedar, minerals and an intriguing truffle note. Juicy flavors of mixed berries, cherry candy, chocolate and vanillin oak. Cherry and mocha heighten the close. $25
90 Strata Vineyards, 2001 Merlot
Napa Valley
Light garnet hue. Stylish aromas of ripe cherry, maple, walnut and an earth note. Vibrant flavors of cherry, raspberry, semisweet chocolate and wood spice have excellent balance. Juicy, intense finish. $34 Pinot Noir
87 Acacia, 2003 Pinot Noir
Carneros, Napa Valley
Dark garnet hue. Cherry and vanilla aromas with coffee and cedar accents. Tart cherry flavors with a mineral influence. Restrained close. $20
88 Alderbrook, 2002 Pinot Noir
Russian River Valley, Sonoma County
Unfiltered ruby hue. Dusty aromas of red fruit and dried leaves. Bright flavors of raspberry, cedar and allspice. Vibrant fruit notes in the finish. $24
88 Beaulieu Vineyard, 2003 Pinot Noir
Carneros
Light ruby hue. Scents of raspberry and cedar. Racy flavors of cranberry and raspberry. Hints of spice and vanilla emerge in the close. $19 - AH
88 Carneros Creek, 2002 Grail Pinot Noir
Carneros
Medium garnet hue with a faded rim. Warm aromas of stewed cherry and maple. Chewy, very ripe flavors of cherry and cedar. Coffee in the finish. $40
89 Clos du Val, 2003 Pinot Noir
Carneros
Deep garnet hue with a ruby rim. Attractive bouquet of licorice, cream, mocha and clove. Ripe, supple flavors of blueberry and plum with mineral undertones. Sweet, fruit-driven finish. $24
90 Elkhorn Peak, 2002 Pinot Noir
Fagan Creek Vineyard, Napa Valley
Bright ruby hue. A whiff of smoke yields to aromas of ripe berries, forest floor and cedar. Gutsy flavors of strawberry and tobacco are well balanced. Lots of juicy fruit in the flavorful close. $30
89 Foley, 2001 Pinot Noir
Santa Maria Valley
Pale garnet hue. Concentrated aromas of stewed strawberry, pencil and new oak. Warm, extracted, tingly flavors of dried cherry and sweetened coffee. Peppery finish. $38
88 Gallo of Sonoma, 2003 Pinot Noir
Sonoma Coast
Bright red hue. Big aromas of plum, earth and black pepper. Extracted but not hot flavors of sweet cherry and vanillin oak. Candied cherry marks the close. $13
88 Gary Farrell, 2003 Pinot Noir
Starr Ridge Vnyd, Russian River Valley
Medium garnet hue. Perfumed aromas of red cherry and forest floor. Lean flavors of raspberry, oak and brown spice. Red berry freshness accents the finish. $32
90 Gary Farrell, 2003 Pinot Noir
Russian River Selection, Russian River Valley
Unfiltered garnet hue. Quite perfumed aromas of cherry blossom and nutmeg. Juicy flavors of cherry, leather and cedar are fuller bodied than suggested by the nose. Tight, youthful close. $45
88 Gloria Ferrer, 2002 Pinot Noir
Carneros
Dusty garnet hue. Lean, lightly floral scents of plum and charred oak. Flavors of ripe cherry, brown sugar and vanilla are more forthcoming than hinted at by the nose. Sweet, though not cloying, finish. $26
90 Gloria Ferrer, 2001 Pinot Noir
Rust Rock Terrace Vineyard, Carneros
Light garnet hue. Nicely reserved aromas of cherry, nutmeg and a crème brûlée note. A silky mouthful of raspberry, spicy cherry, cedar and moist tobacco flavors. Forceful finish. $40
92 Gloria Ferrer, 2001 Pinot Noir
Gravel Knob Vineyard, Carneros
Light brick hue. Integrated aromas of strawberry, slate, dust, cedar and cinnamon. Forward, well-stuffed, flavors of ripe cherry, earth and charred oak. Spicy fruit enlivens the close. $40
91 Harmonique, 2002 The Noble One Pinot Noir
Anderson Valley, Mendocino County
Medium red hue. Warm aromas of ripe cherry, vanilla and brown sugar. Great balance and good weight lift flavors of cherry, red berry and charred oak. Exuberantly fruity finish. $48
88 Harmonique, 2002 Delicacé Pinot Noir
Anderson Valley, Mendocino County
Garnet hue with a faded rim. Lightly floral scents of strawberry and cedar. Subtle flavors of sweet cherry and oak. Soft close. $48
90 Laetitia, 2002 Pinot Noir
Reserve, Arroyo Grande Valley
Black-garnet hue. Lean aromas of raspberry, dust and stone. Flavors of strawberry and nicely integrated wood have a cherry skin texture and are more expressive than suggested by the nose. Spicy cherry in the finish. $40
90 Laetitia, 2003 Pinot Noir
Estate, Arroyo Grande Valley
Bright cherry hue. Freshly turned black earth aromas combine with chocolate, cherry and pencil notes. Rich and creamy with layers of cherry, cranberry and spicy oak flavors. Crisp, zesty close. $25
87 MacMurray Ranch, 2003 Pinot Noir
Sonoma Coast
Vibrant fuchsia hue. Aromas of cherry, tea and citrus with a defined garden nuance. Fresh cherry and raspberry flavors have a youthful tartness. Sweet, earthy finish. $20
90 Marimar Estate, 2002 Cristina Pinot Noir
Don Miguel Vineyard, Russian River Vly
Unfiltered ruby hue. Perfumed, well-integrated aromas of cherry, oak and a hint of smoke. Lively flavors of just-picked cherry, anise and cedar are plushly round. Bright cherry highlights the close. $47
90 Morgan, 2003 Twelve Clones Pinot Noir
Santa Lucia Highlands
Unfiltered garnet hue. Bright aromas of cherry caramel and redwood. Balanced, sweet flavors of tea, strawberry, cedar and vanilla. Crisp, dry finish imparting mineral, citrus and oak flavors. $25
90 Stephen Ross, 2002 Pinot Noir
Bien Nacido Vineyard, Santa Maria Valley
Deep crimson hue. Forward aromas of strawberry, cedar box and black pepper. Bright flavors of cherry and wood spice show great integration of fruit and tannin. Lively, persistent close. $35
88 Stephen Ross, 2002 Pinot Noir
Edna Valley
Ruby-purple hue. Pungent aromas of red fruit, pine resin and bubble gum. Settles down somewhat in the mouth with flavors of juicy strawberry, vanilla and cinnamon. Long finish. $28
87 Valley of the Moon, 2003 Pinot Noir
Carneros
Light brick hue with a faded rim. Lightly perfumed scents of mixed berries and pencil. Seamlessly integrated flavors of cherry and oak with a vanilla note. A slight sourness in the finish. $20
88 Whitford, 2002 Pinot Noir
Haynes Vineyard, Napa Valley
Pale garnet hue with a faded rim. Dainty aromas of ripe cherry, tobacco and menthol. Sweet flavors of cherry, vanillin oak and cigar box. Tingly close. $23
91 ZD, 2003 Pinot Noir
Carneros
Garnet hue. Earthy campfire scents with notes of cherry and vanilla. Crisp flavors of cranberry, licorice and redwood. Red fruit continues in the finish along with a lingering toasted oak nuance. $30
85 Frei Brothers, 2003 Pinot Noir
Reserve, Russian River Valley
- $24
85 Mirassou, 2003 Pinot Noir
Monterey County
- $11
Zinfandel
86 Alex Sotelo Cellars, 2002 Zinfandel
Unfiltered, Dalraddy Vnyd, Napa Valley
Attractive red hue. Spicy scents of cedar, evergreen, citrus peel and black pepper. Drying cherry flavors with an aggressive oakiness that overlays the fruit. Sweet finish struggles under the wood pile. $28
88 Asti Winery, 2002 Cellar No. 8 Zinfandel
North Coast
Reddish-black hue. Bright, briary aromas of red cherry, mixed berries, cedar and vanilla. Tart, dryish flavors of cherry, chalk and vanillin oak sport fine grain tannins. Zesty close. $14
90 Bella Vineyards, 2002 Zinfandel
Big River Ranch, Alexander Valley
Shimmering purple hue. Forward aromas of blueberry, sweet plum, just-picked mint and minerals. Focused flavors of fig, stewed cherry, mocha and espresso. Crisp finish highlighted by chocolate notes. $34
91 Bella Vineyards, 2002 Zinfandel
Lily Hill Estate, Dry Creek Valley
Youthful purple hue with garnet rim. Fresh aromas of cherry, cream and new oak. Tasty cherry flavors with a candied, licorice-like note that takes the edge off the spicy oak. Sweet, lengthy close with very fine, integrated tannins. $30
87 Bourassa Vineyards, 2003 Zinfandel
Odyssey3 , Napa Valley
Deep purple hue. Warm aromas of plum, maple syrup, red meat and dried herbs. Sweet flavors of cherry, strawberry, tobacco and licorice are a bit thin. Spicy close. $32
88 Calistoga Cellars, 2002 Zinfandel
Napa Valley
Brick hue. Earthy aromas of blackberry syrup, mint, oak and pencil. Intense, very sweet flavors of fig, cherry, espresso and tea. Oak notes in the close. $22
86 Camelot, 2002 Zinfandel
California
Ruby hue. Aromas of strawberry and raspberry with a hint of cinnamon. Crisp flavors of blackberry, citrus and vanillin oak. Easy-drinking close. $7
90 Chateau Souverain, 2002 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Voluptuous aromas of black cherry, graphite, mint and violets. Silky flavors of plum, cherry, espresso, pencil and cola. Supple, sweet finish studded with black fruit. $18
90 Dry Creek Vineyard, 2002 Zinfandel
Somers Ranch, Dry Creek Valley
Black hue with a ruby rim. Big aromas of boysenberry, cherry, mint, black pepper and cedar. Bold, grapy flavors of cherry, citrus, freshly ground pepper and cedar. Compact, flavorful finish. $30
88 Dry Creek Vineyard, 2002 Zinfandel
Beeson Ranch, Dry Creek Valley
Black-garnet hue. Warm, peppery aromas of plum, pencil, mint and mahogany. Dry flavors of blackberry, mocha, chalk and minerals. Long, cherry-choked close. $30
90 Dutton Goldfield, 2003 Zinfandel
Dutton Ranch, Morelli Lane, Russian River Vly
Reddish-black hue. Heady aromas of black cherry, prune, pine nut, evergreen and a bell pepper note. Bright, racy flavors of cherry, citrus, wood spice and herbs. Intense, fruity finish. $35
86 Dynamite Vineyards, 2003 Zinfandel
Mendocino County
Deep purple hue. Reserved scents of blueberry, clove, leather and a whiff of mocha. Leanish flavors of cherry, chalk and coffee. Dry close. $17
87 Earth, Zin & Fire, 2003 Zinfandel
Lodi
Purple-black hue. Jammy aromas of blackberry, cedar and juniper. Sweet flavors of boysenberry and oak are a touch hot. Early drinking finish. $16
86 EOS, 2002 Zinfandel
Paso Robles
Ruby hue. Warm aromas of plum, smoke and redwood. Quite spicy flavors of cherry, licorice and chocolate. Tart, astringent finish. $15
87 Estancia, 2002 Zinfandel
Keyes Canyon Ranches, Paso Robles
Purple hue. Meaty scents of plum, Worcestershire sauce and oak spice. Full-bodied flavors of cherry, pencil and pepper. Creamy close. $12
87 Frog's Leap, 2003 Zinfandel
Napa Valley
Viscous purple hue. Black cherry aromas with an herbal note. Crisp cherry flavors with fresh oak accents. Spicy, tannic finish with a metallic bite. $25
87 Kenwood, 2002 Zinfandel
Sonoma County
Shimmering garnet hue. Scents of rose petals, tobacco and oak with the fruit in the background. Flavors of cherry, leather and espresso. Thickly textured close. $16
88 Kenwood, 2002 Zinfandel
Reserve, Sonoma County
Bright red hue. Jammy aromas of plum and blueberry. Full flavored with plenty of blackberry fruit laced with oak and tempered by a defined sweetness. Tannins kick up in the finish. $20
90 Ledson Winery & Vineyard, 2002 Zinfandel
Century Vine, Russian River Valley
Dense garnet hue. Garden scents have a cherry candy-like sweetness. Spicy red fruit flavors with an interesting mix of cinnamon, rhubarb and oak notes. Crisp, tannic finish. A very lively, stylized Zin. $46
87 Lolonis, 2002 Zinfandel
Redwood Valley
Dusty red hue. Perfumed aromas of cherry candy, cola and caramel. A nice combination of cherry skin, plum and earth flavors. Quite spicy close. $18
88 M. Cosentino, 2003 The Zinfandel
Unfined, American Canyon, Napa County
Brick red hue. Intense aromas of cherry, damp stone and cedar. Creamy flavors of blackberry syrup, vanilla, bittersweet chocolate and evergreen. Fruit-laden finish. $30
87 MonteVina, 2002 Terra d'Oro Zinfandel
Amador County
Black-garnet hue. Fragrant aromas of cherries jubilee, mint and tea. Juicy flavors of black cherry, minerals and black pepper. Mocha-laced close. $18
87 Napa Cellars, 2002 Zinfandel
Napa Valley
Attractive garnet hue. Slow-opening bouquet of light plum, date, prune and oak aromas. Bright flavors of cherry, cedar, nutmeg and pepper. Spicy finish. $19
91 Rosenblum Cellars, 2003 Zinfandel
Richard Sauret Vineyards, Paso Robles
Opaque black hue. Intensely aromatic scents of stewed plum, blackberry, bramble, smoke and dried herbs. Port-like texture houses ample flavors of plum, blackberry, treacle and mint. Late harvest richness in the close. $20
91 Rosenblum Cellars, 2003 Zinfandel
Rockpile Road Vineyard, Dry Creek Valley
Dense garnet hue. Layered aromas of black cherry syrup, plum, moist tobacco and cinnamon. Expansive flavors of blackberry, plum, espresso, new oak and minerals are quite supple in the face of their considerable heft. Spicy, lingering finish. $30
91 Rosenblum Cellars, 2002 Zinfandel
Monte Rosso Vineyard, Sonoma Valley
Luminescent purple hue. Very rich aromas of date, black cherry, Worcestershire sauce, coconut, nutmeg and mocha. Lush flavors of blackberry syrup, German chocolate cake, espresso, tobacco and minerals. Thick, warm close. $38
90 Sebastiani, 2003 Old Vines Zinfandel
Sonoma Valley
Youthful garnet hue with a ruby rim. Spicy aromas of pine, clove and black cherry. Driving cherry flavors with a lick of vanilla extract. Even, clean finish with focused fruit, oak and tannins. $24
90 Stephen Ross, 2002 Zinfandel
Dante Dusi Vineyard, Paso Robles
Vibrant ruby hue. Spicy cherry aromas blend with tobacco and cedar notes. Plump cherry and strawberry flavors with an aggressive charred oak overlay. Lingering sweetness in the close. $23
88 Trentadue Winery, 2002 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Purple hue with a reddish tint. Integrated aromas of cherry, black plum, charred oak and clove. Hearty flavors of plum, cherry, minerals and espresso. Clean, racy close. $18
85 Valley of the Moon, 2002 Zinfandel
Sonoma County
Faded garnet hue. Stewed aromas of fig, maple and forest floor. Earthy flavors of blackberry, espresso and cedar. Dry, woodsy finish. $15
91 Vina Robles, 2002 Westside Zinfandel
Paso Robles
Purple hue to the rim. Fresh black fruit aromas with a woodsy, briar-like nuance. Ripe, juicy cherry, plum and oak flavors. Excellent length with the fruit taking on a spicy youthfulness in the close. $24
87 XYZin Winery, 2003 Zinfandel
Sandy Lane Vineyard, Contra Costa County
Black hue. Dusty aromas of black fruit, mint and chocolate. Thick flavors of blackberry, espresso and minerals. Youthful tannins mark the tart finish. $29
84 Lake Sonoma Winery, 2002 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
- $16
85 Talus Collection, 2003 Zinfandel
Lodi
- $8
DeLoach
The following wines were tasted by BuyLine panelist Abraham Horowitz on February 28 at Ortanique on the Mile in Coral Gables, Florida, with DeLoach winemaker Greg La Follette. The wines were not tasted blind.
88 DeLoach, 2003 Estate Chardonnay
Russian River Valley
Fresh scents of pineapple, slate and lemon with a hint of chalk. Creamy flavors of lemon curd with a touch of butter and toasted oak. Lingering notes of white peach in the juicy close. $16
91 DeLoach, 2003 Sauvignon Blanc
Russian River Valley
Clean aromas of mineral, lime and slate with hints of pine and fresh herbs. Lively acidity and juicy flavors of lemon-lime. Lingering Granny Smith apple notes in the crisp finish. $16
90 DeLoach, 2004 Gewürztraminer
Russian River Valley
Powerful scents of lychee nut and pineapple. Juicy flavors of pineapple and lime with a touch of grapefruit. Impressions of candied lime and rose petal in the close. $19
92 DeLoach, 2000 Gewürztraminer
Late Harvest, Russian River Valley
Big aromas of mandarin orange, candied pineapple and mineral. Crisp acidity perfectly balanced by sweet flavors of lemon and pineapple. A blast of mineral in the clean finish. $22
92 DeLoach, 2004 Pinot Noir
Russian River Valley (barrel sample)
Intense aromas of black cherry and cola with a red plum nuance. Rambunctious tannins frame flavors of Bing cherry and Asian spice. Layers of raspberry, vanilla and spice in the evolving close. $TBD
89 DeLoach, 2002 Zinfandel
Russian River Valley
Appealing scents of plum, black cherry and vanilla with a hint of white pepper. Bright acidity and juicy flavors of wild cherry and raspberry. Drying tannins and a touch of oak in the finish. $19
94 DeLoach, 2004 Zinfandel
Russian River Valley (barrel sample)
Inviting scents of plum, blackberry and rum cake with additional notes of bramble and black pepper. Powerful tannins and ultraripe flavors of blackberry and black cherry. Layers of cherry syrup, vanilla and blueberry pie in the endless close. $TBD
About the BuyLine Panel: More than 100 wines are reviewed in every issue of The Wine News. All wines are tasted double-blind and each entry is evaluated and scored based upon individual merit. Wines that score above 70 points are recommended in the BuyLine. Tasting and interpreting wine is a purely subjective exercise; all scores and accompanying tasting notes represent the collective opinions of our panel.
Wine Samples: Send samples for review with retail price affixed to:
The Wine News BuyLine Tasting Panel
1501 Venera Avenue, Suite 320
Coral Gables, FL 33146
Telephone: 305.740.7170
The Panel: Maurice Adams, specialty food and wine merchant; Lyn Farmer, senior staff columnist; Abraham Horowitz, BuyLine panelist; Tom E. Smith, publisher; John Stroker, BuyLine panelist; Fred Tasker, Miami Herald wine critic; Todd M. Wernstrom, executive editor.
Scoring: Tasting notes reflect the panel's collective impressions; scores are averaged and represent the panel's mean. Wines possessing certain criteria will be singled out for special recognition:
Taster's Choice: Wines which display outstanding quality, character and potential.
Best Value Wines of exceptional quality which sell at a moderate price.
Stemware: Riedel Ouverture tasting glasses.
Pricing: Prices vary from state to state. Retail prices listed are approximate.
