Wine Reviews from Wine News
Tasters' Choice Selections
95 Hanna, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Bismark Mt. Vineyard, Sonoma Valley
Opaque black hue. Huge aromas of date, fig, plum, new oak, coffee and a lightening vanilla note. Intense, though supple flavors of cherry, cranberry, plum, cedar and fruitcake spice. Lengthy close highlighted by cherry, mocha and coffee. $61 / 635 cases
95 Guigal, 2002 Hermitage Rouge
Hermitage, France
Deep garnet hue. Concentrated, focused aromas of blackberry, licorice, tar, dried herbs and black pepper. Minerally flavors of blackberry, orange peel, coffee and graphite show no rough edges. Long finish delivers lots of earth notes. $75 / 7,300 cases
94 Giorgio Pira, 1999 Barolo Riserva
Monforte d'Alba, Italy
Light ruby hue with a faded rim. Subtle, floral and very perfumed scents of candied cherry, chestnut and a smoke note. Flavors of red currant and wood spice are more forward than suggested by the nose; fresh, earthy and exuberantly fruity without being encumbered by oak. Long, sweet close. $60 / 200 cases
Best Value Selections
89 Frescobaldi, 2004 Castiglioni
Chianti, Italy
Surprising fuchsia hue. An aromatic nose of cream and cherry with a whiff of black earth. Sweet cherry flavors possess crisp acids and a defined mineral nuance. Polished finish. $13 / 15,000 cases imported
91 G. Cesari, 2002 Mara
Valpolicella Superiore Ripasso, Italy
Crimson hue. Intensely rich aromas of blackberry, fig and sweet bread dough. Velvety flavors of blueberry and Worcestershire sauce. Long, mocha-dusted close carries a defined minerality. $16 / 2,000 cases
88 Georges Dubœuf, 2004 Brouilly Grande Cuvée
Brouilly, France
Medium violet hue. Perfumed aromas of cherry blossom and cinnamon. Balanced, inviting flavors of black cherry, cedar and earth. Drying finish resonates with cedar notes. $12 / 7,000 cases
California
Chardonnay
93 Beringer, 2003 Sbragia Chardonnay
Limited Reserve, Napa Valley
Attractive aromas of oak, honey, nutmeg and mocha. Silky-smooth texture with ripe mango, banana and apricot flavors. Very soft, unctuous finish with a lingering oakiness. $40
92 Beringer, 2003 Chardonnay
Private Reserve, Napa Valley
Forward aromas of orange rind, butterscotch, caramel and new oak. Ripe pineapple and baked apple flavors with a subtle mineral note. Rich, rather sweet close tempered by a good dose of charred oak. $35
92 Calera, 2000 Chardonnay
Mt. Harlan
Ripe honeydew and butterscotch aromas. A silky textured wine with ripe peach, butterscotch and caramel flavors. Lengthy finish shows a blend of toasted oak, a lick of honey and minerals. $34
90 Charles Krug, 2003 Chardonnay
Family Reserve, Carneros Napa Valley
Sliced apple aromas coupled with vanilla extract and clove notes. Supple and ripe with layers of cinnamon, nutmeg, apple and nectarine flavors. An opulent wine with honey and toasted oak punctuating the finish. $24
92 Clos Pégase, 2003 Chardonnay
Mitsuko's Vnyd, Carneros, Napa Valley
Fresh aromas of pear, apple and peach laced with a defined toasted oakiness. Supple and sweet with flavors of apple, vanilla, clove and a note of nutmeg. Great weight with a lingering, honeyed close. $16
90 Dry Creek Vineyard, 2003 Chardonnay
Saralee's Vineyard, Russian River Valley
Clean aromas of nutmeg, oak and clove. Front-row flavors of apple cider, cinnamon and charred oak. Soft, friendly finish shows honey and apple. $30
92 Fisher Vineyards, 2003 Chardonnay
Mountain Estate Vnyd, Sonoma County
Shy at first, then peach, lemon drop, banana and oak aromas appear. Rich flavors of sliced orange, coconut and minerals have cleansing acidity. A well-oaked close delivers layers of tropical fruit. $45
91 Gary Farrell, 2003 Chardonnay
Cresta Ridge Vnyd, Russian River Valley
Big toasted oak aromas with sliced peach in the mix. Ripe flavors of apple, peach, oak and clove. A lively, youthful wine that's packed with fresh fruit and crisp acidity; will continue to improve. $38
88 Gary Farrell, 2003 Chardonnay
Russian River Selection, Russian River Vly
Fresh aromas of banana, peach and nutmeg. Crisp and somewhat tart with new oak and grapefruit flavors. Lean, racy close. $32
87 Hess Collection, 2003 Chardonnay
Napa Valley
Uplifting aromas of peach, apricot and toasted oak. Lively and crisp white peach flavors. Squeaky-clean finish imparting clove, oak and citrus flavors. $19
92 Landmark, 2003 Overlook Chardonnay
Sonoma, Monterey, Santa Barbara Counties
Forward aromas of taffy apple, melted butter and charred oak. Supple texture with honey, peach and mango flavors. The sweetness builds toward the finish with brown spice, apple and vanilla notes. $25
91 Ortman Family Vineyards, 2003 Chardonnay
Edna Valley
Spicy oak aromas followed by peach and mango. Nice balance between oak and fruit with peach and apple being the major players. Vibrant with an attractive charred oak nuance in the close. $25
86 Ravenswood, 2003 Chardonnay
Vintners Blend, California
Fresh sliced apple and honey aromas. Fruity flavors of peach, nectarine, banana and a note of oak. Soft, juicy finish. $11
86 Raymond Estate, 2003 Chardonnay
Monterey
Butternut and pecan aromas with a wisp of clove. Crisp flavors of peach, apple and oak. A well-structured wine that closes on an acidic note. $13
86 Sebastiani, 2003 Chardonnay
Sonoma County
Forward aromas of vanilla, clove and oak. Ripe and ready flavors of pineapple, peach and vanilla. Easy-drinking, soft finish with a toasted oak nuance. $13
85 Beaulieu Vineyard, 2003 Chardonnay
Napa Valley
$19
84 Kenwood, 2004 Chardonnay
Sonoma County
$15
85 M. Cosentino, 2004 The Chard
California
$16
85 Pepi, 2004 Chardonnay
California
$9
85 Rodney Strong, 2003 Chardonnay
Sonoma County
$15
84 Leaping Lizard, 2003 Chardonnay
Napa Valley
$10
85 William Hill Winery, 2003 Chardonnay
Napa Valley
$13
Cabernets & Blends
90 Arrowood, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Unfiltered-Unfined, Sonoma County
Aromas of cherry, smoky oak, cola and maple are a bit warm. Friendly tannins frame flavors of cassis, pecan, chocolate and sweet oak. Lots of cherry in the long finish. $45
89 Charles Krug, 2002 Generations
Family Reserve, Napa Valley
Spicy, herbal aromas of plum, pencil, clove and smoke. Sweet, crisp flavors of blackberry, maple and gravel. Ripe fruit lifts the otherwise tight close. $42
92 Chimney Rock, 2002 Elevage
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Smoky aromas of plum, cola nut, red licorice and wet stone. Very sweet, forward flavors of blueberry jam, cherry, mint, pencil and charred oak. Blackberry and coffee notes in the lengthy finish. $76
92 Chimney Rock, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Minty aromas of boysenberry, redwood, dust and new oak. Viscous flavors of cherry, semisweet chocolate, coffee and anise. Long close features red berry and mocha notes. $100
92 Clos du Val, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Napa Valley
Dusty scents of cherry, pencil shavings, cedar and sweet pecan. Hefty flavors of sweet-tart cherry, mocha, maple and coffee are laced by a distinct minerality. Brown spices in the close. $95
88 Cosentino Winery, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Aromas of blueberry, coffee, charred oak and a resin note. Bright flavors of blackberry and citrus show tangy acidity and tannins. Crisp finish. $45
93 Dominus Estate, 2002 Dominus
Napa Valley
Warm, pungent aromas of raspberry, vanilla, maple and smoke. Well-integrated flavors of cherry, licorice, pencil shavings and charred oak exhibit great depth and complexity. Smooth, spicy close shows ample fruit. $109
89 Flora Springs, 2002 Trilogy
Napa Valley
Sweet, treacly aromas of blueberry, date and coconut. Quite earthy flavors of cherry, mint and lots of oak. Creamy finish. $60
93 Hess Collection, 2001 The Lion
Napa Valley
Forward aromas of blueberry, date, coconut and coffee. Lithe, silky flavors of mixed berries, plum, pencil, espresso and walnut. Soft, lingering finish overflows with ripe fruit. $115
90 Kathryn Hall, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Sacrashe Vnyd, Rutherford, Napa Valley
Faintly floral scents of cherry, underbrush and clove. Crisp, dry flavors of plum, cranberry, espresso and earth. Redwood marks the close. $65
91 Kuleto Estate, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Lean aromas of bittersweet chocolate, coffee and clove. Sweet, expressive flavors of blackberry, cherry, moist tobacco and mocha. Edgy finish trumpets lots of wood spice. $60
90 Marshall Family Cellars, 2001 Cabernet Franc
Napa Valley
Pungent, Loire-like aromas of blackberry, rhubarb and sweet smoke. Balanced flavors of mixed berries, tobacco and cedar are extracted without being overripe. A bacon fat note lifts the finish. $24
88 Nickel & Nickel, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Branding Iron, Oakville, Napa Valley
Cedary scents of cherry, menthol and forest floor. Dry, tart flavors of raspberry, earth and mocha. Puckering close. $75
92 Nickel & Nickel, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Dragonfly Vineyard, St. Helena, Napa Vly
Meaty aromas of blackberry, dust, mocha and lots of earth. Minerally flavors of cherry, coffee and cola. Hearty close shows the wine's excellent balance. $90
88 Nickel & Nickel, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
John C. Sullenger Vnyd, Oakville, Napa Vly
Dusty aromas of plum, clove and leather. Very lean flavors of raspberry, citrus and coffee. Tooth-coating, pencil-laced finish. $75
92 Nickel & Nickel, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Stelling Vineyard, Oakville, Napa Valley
Intriguing combination of tar-y and floral nuances frame aromas of plum, root beer and lanolin. Flavors of blueberry, cherry and chocolate are sweeter than suggested by the nose. Vibrant close. $130
92 Nickel & Nickel, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Vogt Vineyard, Howell Mt, Napa Valley
Wonderfully warm aromas of blueberry, plum, tobacco and espresso show just a touch of herbs. Concentrated, exotic flavors of cherry, graphite, minerals and bittersweet chocolate. Lasting finish has a prickly, youthful edge. $75
91 Oakville Ranch, 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Intense aromas of plum, cherry, maple and graphite. Polished, racy flavors of blackberry, semisweet chocolate, minerals and cedar. Close is sweet without being overdone. $50
92 Ristow Estate, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Quinta de Pedras Vineyard, Napa Valley
Heady aromas of blueberry, pencil, brown spice and an herbal note. Huge flavors of blackberry, citrus and smoke are even more forthcoming than the generous nose. Supple close loaded with black fruit. $60
Rutherford Hill, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon 90 Napa Valley Nuanced aromas of black currant, mocha and touches of herbs and cedar. Chalky flavors of brambly blueberry, minerals and mocha. Plush finish. $35 93 Signorello, 2002 Padrone
Unfiltered, Napa Valley
Subtle scents of blackberry, cherry, eucalyptus, dust and cola. Spicy flavors of black cherry, chocolate and minerals are quite extracted without being heavy. Cherry and mocha highlight the frisky finish. $95
90 St. Clement, 2002 Oroppas
Napa Valley
Pungent, smoky aromas of brambly red fruit, maple and mocha. Chalky flavors of cherry, chocolate, tea and oak. Warm, spicy close. $50
89 Stags' Leap Winery, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Reserved scents of red fruit, oak char and clove. Big, racy flavors of raspberry, plum, tobacco and cedar. Spicy finish. $45
90 Whitehall Lane, 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Napa Valley
Youthful aromas of blackberry, chocolate, pencil and smoke. Tight flavors of spicy cherry, baker's chocolate and oak. Crisp acidity softens somewhat in the lengthy close. $75
Pinot Noir
92 Alderbrook, 2003 Pinot Noir
Russian River Valley
Uplifting aromas of cherry, rose petal, campfire and clove. Sweet and forthcoming with flavors of cherry, caramel and a note of milk chocolate. Finish imparts a combination of cherry and red licorice. $24
93 Amici Cellars, 2003 Pinot Noir
Mendocino
Spicy redwood, cedar, cranberry and tea aromas. Sweet as well as peppery with crisp cranberry flavors and fine-grain tannins. Lasting creamy finish shows red licorice and a smoky nuance. $42
90 Baileyana, 2002 Pinot Noir
Grand Firepeak Cuvée, Edna Valley
Lightly floral aromas of cherry, oak and dust. Focused cherry flavors have a taut texture. Lively close is loaded with red fruit notes. $38
87 Beaulieu Vineyard, 2003 Pinot Noir
Carneros, Napa Valley
Fresh cherry scents with secondary aromas of coffee and mushroom. Flavors of cranberry, tea and orange peel. Crisp finish. $19
89 Belle Glos, 2003 Pinot Noir
Taylor Lane Vineyard, Sonoma County
Warm, smoky aromas of rhubarb and cedar. Moderately sweet flavors of cherry, cedar and lots of earth. Intensely fruity close. $50
87 Beringer, 2004 Pinot Noir
Napa Valley
Cranberry and cherry juice aromas. Good weight reflecting raspberry and cranberry flavors. Spicy, earthy finish with a licorice-like sweetness. $16
90 Calera, 2002 Pinot Noir
Central Coast
Smoky aromas of raspberry, cedar box and earth. Intensely sweet flavors of strawberry and oak spice. Sweet-tart fruit and wood notes in the close. $20
88 Calera, 2001 Pinot Noir
Mills Vineyard, Mt. Harlan
Aromas of rhubarb, cedar and tobacco show the warmth of alcohol. Old World-style flavors of mixed berries and oak. Red fruit marks the finish. $40
91 Calera, 2002 Pinot Noir
Ryan Vineyard, Mt. Harlan
Warm aromas of raspberry preserves and cedar. Adroitly balanced flavors of red cherry, spicy tobacco and forest floor. Tooth-coating finish. $40
94 Calera, 2001 Pinot Noir
Selleck Vineyard, Mt. Harlan
Beautifully integrated, floral, perfumed scents of cooked cherry, nutmeg and black pepper. Continues gracefully in the mouth with flavors of peppery strawberry and cedar. Long, cherry-soaked close shows the wine's admirable aging potential. $55
88 Cosentino Winery, 2002 Pinot Noir
Unfined-Unfiltered, Russian River Valley
Raspy, peppery aromas of cherry and brown sugar. Flavors of plum, cedar and maple are quite sweet. Long finish. $35
88 Etude, 2003 Pinot Noir
Carneros
A barnyard note burns off to reveal perfumed cherry candy scents. Smooth flavors of strawberry jam and earth. Fresh close. $40
92 Foley, 2003 Pinot Noir
Santa Rita Hills, Rancho Santa Rosa
Cherry and cream soda aromas with sliced orange notes. Delicate and spicy; first with cherry and cedar flavors followed by mocha, clove and white pepper. The finish sweetens up with a mix of brown spices and a defined creaminess. $38
90 J. Jacaman, 2003 Pinot Noir
Russian River Valley
A rich bouquet of plum, fig, mocha and maraschino cherry. Exotic flavors of stewed cherry, caramel, fig and chocolate. Soft close sports brown spices and a root beer-like sweetness. $35
86 Ortman Family Vineyards, 2003 Pinot Noir
Santa Rita Hills
Smoky, charred oak aromas with a hint of Worcestershire sauce. Peppery with cranberry flavors and aggressive tannins. Spicy finish. $30
91 Ortman Family Vineyards, 2003 Pinot Noir
Willamette Valley
Forward aromas of cranberry, mocha and menthol. Lots of cherry, oak and licorice flavors with aggressive tannins clamping down on the promising fruit. This is a big, fruit-driven Pinot that needs time to turn the corner. $30
87 Paraiso, 2003 Pinot Noir
Santa Lucia Highlands, Monterey County
Perfumed scents of black cherry and forest floor. Fresh, fruity flavors of cherry and black pepper. Abrupt finish brings it down a notch. $22
88 Paraiso, 2002 Pinot Noir
West Terrace, Santa Lucia Highlands
Aromas of plum preserves, brown sugar and well-integrated oak. Fruit-forward flavors of cherry and earth. A hint of dried tobacco in the close. $40
90 Robert Mondavi Winery, 2002 Pinot Noir
Reserve, Carneros
Pretty floral aromas of raspberry and sweet oak are pleasingly reserved. Flavors of cherry, drying cedar and smoke are more intense than suggested by the nose. Big, fruit-laden finish. $50
87 Rodney Strong, 2003 Pinot Noir
Russian River Valley, Sonoma County
Woodsy campfire aromas with a hint of orange peel. Bright cherry flavors coupled with cedar and minerals. Lengthy close. $19
88 Rodney Strong, 2002 Pinot Noir
Reserve, Jane's Vnyd, Russian River Vly
Pungent mushroom aromas with accents of charred oak and a clove. Forward cherry fruit flavors with an earthy, tea-like accent. Delicate, airy finish offers a kiss of oakiness. $35
93 Taz, 2003 Pinot Noir
Fiddlestix Vineyard, Santa Rita Hills
Charred oak, graphite and menthol aromas. Loaded with juicy black cherry flavors with powerful tannins. The finish is vibrant and lasting, however the wine needs time to soften. $35
Australia
Shiraz
90 Davey Family Vineyards, 2003 The Gate Shiraz
McLaren Vale
Very smoky aromas of blackberry and earth. Extracted, warm, spicy flavors of black currant, fig and semisweet chocolate. Black coffee notes enliven the finish. $32
87 Davey Family Vineyard, 2004 Red Knot Shiraz
McLaren Vale
Ripe plum and vanilla aromas. Lively plum and blueberry flavors with polished tannins and pinpoint acidity. A lengthy, fruit-driven close. $12
87 Greg Norman Estate, 2003 Shiraz
Limestone Coast
Aromas of mint, oak, pencil and campfire. Stewed cherry, clove and nutmeg flavors. Earthy finish with tea and tobacco notes. $16
89 Greg Norman Estates, 2000 Shiraz
Reserve, Padthaway
Big, pungent aromas of fig, fruitcake spice and tar. A molasses-like sweetness marks flavors of plum, black earth and ample oak. Long, warm close. $40
86 Jacob's Creek, 2002 Shiraz
Reserve, South Australia
Heady aromas of mint, plum, pencil and blueberry. Peppery black cherry flavors with aggressive oak and tannins Dry, flinty, mineral-like finish. $13
91 Jim Barry, 2003 Shiraz
The Lodge Hill, Clare Valley
Ripe aromas of mocha, cherry and mint. Vibrant cherry flavors followed by layers of mint, vanilla, blueberry and new oak. Very clean, polished finish has youthful spiciness. $17
87 Katnook Estate, 2002 Shiraz
Coonawarra
Primary aromas of cedar, earth and black pepper muscle the fruit to the background. Lean flavors of mixed berries and cedar box. Dusty close. $22
91 Penfolds, 2001 St. Henri Shiraz
South Australia
Tar-y aromas of roasted plum, licorice and earth. Minerally, concentrated flavors of blackberry and citrus sport a lightening vanilla note. Tobacco and cedar mark the lingering finish. $40
91 Penfolds, 2002 Shiraz
Magill Estate, South Australia
Pretty violet notes surround serious aromas of blackberry, pencil shavings and earth. Rich, chocolaty flavors of blackberry, fig and dusty oak. Long close highlighted by mixed berry notes. $50
88 Penfolds, 2002 Thomas Hyland Shiraz
South Australia
Bright aromas of cherry, coconut and blueberry. Well balanced with cherry and plum flavors laced with oak and cedar that punctuate the finish. $15
87 Penfolds, 2002 Bin 128 Shiraz
Coonawarra
Dusty scents of oak and black pepper. Woody flavors of tart red fruit and citrus. Tobacco marks the close. $22
90 Penfolds, 2002 Bin 28 Shiraz
Kalimna Vineyard, South Australia
Subtle aromas of blackberry, licorice and a vanilla note. Concentrated flavors of mixed berries, espresso and chocolate. Intense, well-fruited close. $22
92 Penfolds, 2002 RWT Shiraz
Barossa Valley
Slow-to-open aromas of plum, citrus, tar and black earth show a hint of sweetness. Supple, concentrated flavors of mixed berries and coffee. Espresso-soaked finish goes on and on. $70
89 Peter Lehmann, 2000 Eight Songs Shiraz
Barossa
Forward aromas of black fruit, citrus peel, anise and a petrol note. Chalky, concentrated flavors of plum, mocha and treacle. Wood shows itself in the close. $45
87 Peter Lehmann, 2002 Shiraz
Barossa
Minty aromas of vanilla and brown spice. Crisp cherry flavors with redwood and cedar notes. Finishes on a sweet brown sugar note. $16
87 Rosemount, 2000 Show Reserve Shiraz
McLaren Vale, Langhorne Creek
Aromas of smoke, cedar and tobacco crowd the brambly fruit notes. Minerally flavors of red berry and black pepper. Cedary close. $24
86 Shingleback, 2003 Shiraz
McLaren Vale
Pungent, fruity aromas of blackberry and tobacco. Flavors of orange, black fruit and smoke are earthier than the nose. Woody finish. $20
86 Stonehaven, 2003 Shiraz
Winemaker's Selection, South Australia
Spicy aromas of white pepper, clove, maple and cherry. Pungent cherry flavors with notes of minerals, oak and a tobacco. Crisp close. $13
87 Taltarni, 2001 Shiraz
Pyrenees, Victoria
Wood-dominated aromas of blackberry, coffee and black pepper. Tight flavors of black fruit, earth and oak. Warm, spicy finish. $20
88 Taltarni, 2003 Shiraz
Heathcote
Scents of brambly berries and tobacco. Forward, well-fruited flavors of red berry and pepper. Spicy close is lively without being stinging. $35
88 Vasse Felix, 2003 Adams Road Shiraz
Margaret River
Upfront charred oak aromas followed by clove and ripe plum notes. Crisp and sweet with with plenty of cherry flavors laced with youthful tannins and fresh oak that lead to a racy, peppery close. $15
90 Wirra Wirra Vineyards, 2002 R.S.W. Shiraz
McLaren Vale
Warm, enveloping aromas of fig, moist tobacco and leather. Mineral-laden flavors of blackberry and sweetened black coffee. Long, lean finish. $55
88 Wirra Wirra Vineyards, 2002 Shiraz
McLaren Vale
Smoky aromas of blackberry, tar and black pepper. Focused flavors of blackberry, licorice, oak char and black pepper. Earthy close. $27
84 Hardys, 2003 Shiraz
South Eastern Australia
$6
85 Marquee, 2004 Classic Shiraz
Victoria
$10
84 Palandri, 2002 Boundary Road Shiraz
Western Australia
$11
85 Peace Family Vineyard, 2004 Shiraz
South Eastern Australia
$8
85 Tintara, 2003 Shiraz
McLaren Vale, South Australia
$8
85 Tyrrell's Wines, 2003 Lost Block Shiraz
South Eastern Australia
$14
84 Wirra Wirra Vineyards, 2003 Shiraz
Scrubby Rise, South Australia
$12
France
Beaujolais
87 Georges Dubœuf, 2004 Mâcon-Villages
Mâcon-Villages
Exuberant aromas of pear and apple. Bracing flavors of red apple and baking spice. Fresh close. $9
86 Georges Dubœuf, 2004 Régnié
Régnié
Lightly perfumed aromas of candied cherry and vanilla. Sweet-tart raspberry flavors are well matched by tangy acidity. Food-friendly finish. $10
86 Georges Dubœuf, 2004 Fleurie
Fleurie
Earthy, peppery aromas jettison the fruit to the background. Strawberry and black pepper flavors are framed by drying tannins. Spicy finish. $14
85 Georges Dubœuf, 2004 Beaujolais-Villages
Beaujolais-Villages
$9
Bordeaux
89 Château Boutisse, 2003 St.-Émilion
St.-Émilion Grand Cru
Pungent, somewhat herbaceous plum aromas. Concentrated flavors of blackberry, dried tobacco and minerals. Lean close shows coffee notes. $30
93 Château Lascombes, 2003 Margaux
Margaux
Enticing aromas of black cherry and plum with secondary nuances of smoke, tar and sweet tobacco. Velvety tannins, powerful acidity and juicy flavors of black cherry and raspberry. Espresso and tobacco notes in the lingering close. $59
88 Château Lyonnat, 2003 Lussac-St.-Émilion
Lussac-St.-Émilion
Warm aromas of licorice and forest floor with light fruit notes. Balanced flavors of plum, dust and cedar. Drying tannins show themselves in the finish. $20
Rhône Whites
88 Guigal, 2003 Côtes-du-Rhône Blanc
Côtes-du-Rhône
Waxy aromas of pear, white flowers and a honey note. Fresh flavors of melon and pear. A dry nuttiness in the finish. $12
91 Guigal, 2003 St.-Joseph Blanc
St.-Joseph
Rich aromas of pear, honeysuckle, butterscotch and dust. Round flavors of apricot pit and citrus are quite floral. Honeyed close. $27
92 Guigal, 2004 Condrieu
Condrieu
Very fragrant aromas of stone fruit, white flowers and a butter note. Flavors of apricot, bee pollen and dried tobacco don't have the appellation's typical oiliness presently but should round out in time. Finish exhibits brown spice. $50
Rhône Reds
87 Maison Bouachon, 2003 Pierrelongue
Vacqueyras
Aromas of stone and minerals with accents of blackberry and currant. Round mouth-feel on entry with ripe cherry and continued currant nuances. Slightly drying close. $20
91 Maison Bouachon, 2003 Duc de Montfort
Gigondas
Pretty nose with concentrated scents of crushed raspberry, strawberry and light floral notes. Silky palate impressions with sweet cherry flavors that accompany earthy highlights. Smooth finish showcases oak, spices and dried berry notes. $23
90 Maison Bouachon, 2003 La Tiare du Pape
Châteauneuf-du-Pape
Sweet bouquet of raspberry, maple and a hint of rose petals. More complex flavors on the palate with forest floor, bramble and truffle notes. Soft on the finish with continued oak and leather accents. $34
89 Maison Bouachon, 2003 Roquebrussane
Saint-Joseph
Very aromatic scents of sweet maple, blueberry and a hint of pepper. Round, slightly sweet cherry entry that evolves to tart berries, currant and gravelly impressions. Dry close. $30
88 Guigal, 2003 Côtes-du-Rhône Rouge
Côtes-du-Rhône
Big, grapy aromas of boysenberry and grilled meat. Earthy flavors of plum, leather and smoke. Lean close. $12
90 Guigal, 2001 St.-Joseph Rouge
St.-Joseph
Peppery aromas of plum, bramble and smoke. Thick flavors of blackberry, tar and licorice have inviting acidity. A citrus note freshens the finish. $27
89 Guigal, 2001 Crozes-Hermitage Rouge
Crozes-Hermitage
Initial notes of smoke and bell pepper yield to aromas of black fruit and grilled meat. Vibrant flavors of blackberry, pencil and pepper shine thanks to citrusy acidity. Smoke dominates the close. $20
91 Guigal, 2001 Gigondas
Gigondas
Pretty scents of blackberry, cherry, licorice and smoke. Sweet, silky flavors of cherry, black pepper and earth. Agile close loaded with fruit. $25
92 Guigal, 2001 Châteauneuf-du-Pape Rouge
Châteauneuf-du-Pape
Reserved aromas of plum, minerals, tar and a pretty lavender note. Velvety flavors of cherry, citrus and oak char are ripe without being overly extracted. Cracked black pepper in the finish. $40
94 Guigal, 2001 Brune et Blonde
Côte-Rôtie
Subtly intense aromas of mixed berries, anise and black pepper. Full-throttle flavors of cherry, smoke, tobacco and lots of black pepper. Citrus notes keep the close nicely in check. $65
Italy
Pinot Grigio
90 Attems, 2004 Pinot Grigio
Collio
Nutty scents of red apple and flowers. Luscious flavors of melon, pear and a sawdust note have ample body. Ripe apple in the close. $18
87 Campanile, 2004 Pinot Grigio
Venezie IGT
Aromas of lemon and white flowers have an herbal overlay. Round red apple flavors. Very clean, refreshing finish. $11
86 Ecco Domani, 2004 Pinot Grigio
Venezie IGT
Dusty scents of sweet apple, stone and straw. Soft peach flavors. Plush close. $11
86 Gabbiano, 2004 Pinot Grigio
Venezie IGT
Aromas of sliced pear and wet stone. Fruity flavors of apple and honeydew melon. A touch of sweetness in the finish. $10
87 Montresor, 2004 La Colombaia Pinot Grigio
Valdadige
Subtle scents of lemon and straw. Fresh flavors of red apple and citrus exhibit cleansing acidity. Sweet apple in the close. $16
85 Bella Sera, 2004 Pinot Grigio
Venezie IGT
$8
85 Cesari Duetorri, 2004 Pinot Grigio
Venezie IGT
$10
Other Whites
88 Attems, 2004 Pinot Bianco
Collio
Fresh, juicy green apple aromas show sweet hints. Appetite-whetting flavors of pear and apple bulk up a bit as the wine warms. Minerally finish. $18
90 Attems, 2004 Tocai Friulano
Collio
Aromas of honeydew melon and gravel show an herbal nuance. A varietal herbaceousness frames flavors of peach and apple. Soft close. $18
91 Attems, 2003 Cicinis
Collio
Ripe, honeyed aromas of stone fruit and butterscotch. Big, yet supple flavors of pineapple and buttery oak with a rich, clean close. $35
90 Frescobaldi, 2002 Castello di Pomino Benefizio
Pomino Bianco
Ripe aromas of apricot, beeswax, caramel and butterscotch. Very rich flavors of pineapple, paraffin and oak char. Long honeyed finish manages to stay lively in spite of its heft. $28
Amarone & Valpolicella
92 Fabiano, 2000 Amarone
Amarone della Valpolicella Classico
Perfumed aromas of cherries jubilée, tobacco and graphite. Silky, lithe, yet concentrated flavors of red cherry and bittersweet chocolate. Mineral and chocolate notes make for a luscious finish. $40
93 Fabiano, 1998 I Fondatori Amarone
Amarone della Valpolicella Classico
Warm, subtle aromas of cherry blossom, dusty minerals and cedar. Ample flavors of candied cherry, date, espresso and graphite. Black walnut and a correct bitter note in the long close. $50
94 San Rustico, 2001 La Sorellina
Valpolicella Classico Superiore
Minerally aromas of black cherry, soy sauce and cigar box. Concentrated, yet deftly balanced flavors of cherry, smoked meat and oak spice. Long, tooth-coating finish. $30
88 Tenuta Sant'Antonio, 1999 La Bandina
Valpolicella Superiore
Spicy aromas of stewed plum and earth show the warmth of alcohol. Tangy flavors of cherries jubilée, citrus and wood. Well-focused close. $24
89 Tenuta Sant'Antonio, 2000 Monti Garbi
Valpolicella Superiore
Mature aromas of red berry and wood spice. Sweet, smooth flavors of cherry compote and bread dough. Long, elegant finish. $24
90 Tenuta Sant'Antonio, 2000 Amarone
Amarone della Valpolicella
Intense aromas of dried black fruit, earth, soy and fruitcake. Luscious flavors of plum compote and coffee. Sweet bread dough highlights the close. $50
Other Veneto Reds
86 Bertani, 2003 Arminio Merlot
Veneto IGT
Warm, brambly scents of blackberry and cedar. Flavors of cherry, sweet tobacco and earth. Sweet-tart finish. $12
89 Tenuta Sant'Antonio, 2000 Cabernet Sauvignon
Capitel del Monte, Veneto IGT
Dusty, herbal aromas of raisin, fig and graphite. Soft flavors of dried cherry, date and fruitcake spice. Sweet close. $35
Barolo
92 Cascina Gagliassi, 1999 Riserva
Barolo
Exotic aromas of pecan and maple with a whiff of Sherry. Racy flavors of citrus, resin and walnut possess near-biting acidity. Brown spice punctuates the finish with a lingering Sherry note. $55
92 Giorgio Pira, 2000 Barolo
Monforte d'Alba
Floral aromas of baking spice and cedar place the fruit in the background at present. Flavors of ripe cherry, sweet oak and tar are more forthcoming than the nose. Tart red fruit marks the close. $60
91 San Biagio, 1999 Barolo
La Morra
Warm aromas of dried fruit and lots of red licorice with notes of fig and oak char. Velvety texture and citrusy acidity frame flavors of tart cherry and cedar. Youthful finish shows smoky notes. $45
93 San Biagio, 2000 Barolo
La Morra
Beautifully integrated, subtle aromas of red berry, strawberry, cedar and just-picked rose petals. Inviting flavors of dried red cherry, orange peel and a tar note are sweetly focused. Intense close. $45
90 Viberti Giovanni, 2000 Buon Padre
Barolo
Forward aromas of cedar, alcohol, clove and resin. Peppery flavors of clove, citrus peel and a hint of methylate have lively acidity. Racy finish ends on a sweet brown sugar note. $51
Other Piedmont Reds
92 Batasiolo, 2000 Barbaresco
Barbaresco
Pungent and earthy aromas with a whiff of Sherry and a slight burnt nuance. Exotic nutmeg, pecan, brown sugar and Sherry flavors. Peppery finish with nutmeg and orange peel accents. $40
86 Batasiolo, 2002 Sovrana
Barbera d'Alba
Lightly perfumed scents of blackberry, wood spice and black pepper. Tart cherry and earth flavors are lashed by bracing acidity. Puckering close. $21
88 Batasiolo, 2003 Dolcetto d'Alba
Dolcetto d'Alba
Warm, peppery aromas of blueberry and chocolate. Creamy flavors of blackberry, black pepper and cedar. Dry finish. $15
90 Cascina Gagliassi, 1998 Barricate di Notte
Langhe Rosso
Pretty floral aromas of dried cherry, citrus peel and wood spice. Youthful, quite lively flavors of mixed berries, baker's chocolate and an ample dose of wood. Tight finish. $50
88 Dezzani, 2003 Il Camürot
Dolcetto d'Alba
Reserved, perfumed, sweet black currant aromas. Raspy flavors of mixed berries and earth. Gripping close. $16
93 Gillardi, 2002 HARYS Syrah
VDT Piemonte Rosso
Deep aromas of mixed berries, grill pan and black pepper. Chalky texture and bright acidity frame flavors of blackberry, minerals and tobacco. Big finish concludes on a tart fruit note. $60
90 Poderi la Collina, 2003 Labbra di Giada
Dolcetto di Dogliani
Rich, spicy flavors of mixed berries, mocha and sweetened coffee. Sweet, peppery flavors of black currant and semisweet chocolate. Oaky tannins dominate the close. $30
90 San Biagio, 2001 Janin
Langhe Rosso
Earthy aromas of tar and tobacco place the black fruit in the background. Soft, tangy flavors of fig, plum and molasses. Sweet smoke highlights the finish. $40
84 Batasiolo, 2002 Barbera d'Alba
Barbera d'Alba
$14
Chianti
86 Banfi, 2003 Chianti Classico
Chianti Classico
Floral aromas of plum, oak and a smoke note. Soft, dried cherry flavors. Tart finish. $9
89 Carpineto, 2002 Chianti Classico
Chianti Classico
Big, tar-y, earth aromas place the fruit in the background. Round flavors of cherry, raspberry and deftly integrated oak. Red fruit marks the close. $21
88 Carpineto, 2000 Riserva
Chianti Classico
Warm aromas of plum, oak and smoke. Concentrated flavors of dried red fruit, espresso and minerals. Tart cherry in the finish. $27
91 Da Vinci, 2003 Chianti Classico
Chianti Classico
Bright aromas of cherry and pencil show excellent balance. Sweet-tart flavors of black cherry, nutmeg and minerals. Wood tannins mark the close. $20
90 Da Vinci, 2002 Riserva
Chianti Classico
Rich but not overly exuberant aromas of blackberry, citrus and brown spice. Very lively, tangy flavors of plum, sweet oak and mocha continue through to the finish. $20
90 Dievole, 2000 Novecento Riserva
Chianti Classico
Big, pungent, warm aromas of black fruit and earth. Smooth, concentrated flavors of ripe blackberry, sweet oak and pencil. Long close exudes mocha and espresso notes. $40
88 Frescobaldi, 2001 Nipozzano Riserva
Chianti Rúfina
Healthy aromas of cherry cola, evergreen and clove. Earthy flavors of baker's chocolate and stewed cherry. Spicy close continues on a earthy path. $22
92 Frescobaldi, 2001 Montesodi
Castello di Nipozzano, Chianti Rúfina
Attractive aromas of black cherry, blueberry and a peppery edge. Great weight and intensity with plenty of plum and cherry flavors with a slight taste of pencil lead that lingers in the finish. $45
86 Gabbiano, 2002 Chianti Classico
Chianti Classico
A bouquet of tea, glove leather and dried leaves. Crisp, peppery flavors with a medicinal accent. Light, dry close has a bell pepper spiciness. $13
abbiano, 2002 Riserva
90 Chianti Classico Fresh vanillin and cherry aromas. Thick and rich with cherry, clove and white pepper flavors. The sweetness powers up in the finish with lingering notes of maple, nutmeg and brown sugar. $17
87 Luiano, 1999 Riserva
Chianti Classico
Barnyardy aromas of earth and oak with the fruit notes developing with air. Balanced flavors of strawberry and cedar. Lots of cherry in the finish. $25
87 Villa di Campobello, 2004 Chianti
Chianti
Wood scents layer aromas of macerated cherry and tar. Lively flavors of sweet red cherry and burnt sugar. A pleasant sour note in the medium close. $11
85 Gabbiano, 2003 Chianti
Chianti
$10
Other Tuscan Reds
86 Carpineto, 2003 Dogajolo
Toscana IGT
Perfumed aromas of raspberry and cedar. Bright flavors of sweet cherry and earth. Lively close. $13
88 Carpineto, 1999 Riserva
Vino Nobile di Montepulciano
Aromas of plum, walnut and damp stone. Lean flavors of crushed berry, maple and wood. Tight close. $33
88 Carpineto, 1999 Farnito Cabernet Sauvignon
Toscana IGT
Pungent scents of black cherry, cedar and clove. Tart cherry flavors with charred oak and mineral notes. Earthy finish with a smoky bacon fat nuance. $31
93 Castello Banfi, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Brunello di Montalcino
Fresh cherry, tea and cedar aromas. Delicate flavors of cherry, tea and nutmeg laced with fine tannins. Lingering sweetness in the close with cedar, citrus peel and black pepper accents. $68
90 Castello Banfi, 2002 Cum Laude
Sant'Antimo
Warm aromas of stewed plum, smoke and tobacco. Gritty flavors of blackberry, earth and coffee grounds. Tight, youthful finish. $35
88 Castello Banfi, 2001 Mandrielle Merlot
Sant'Antimo
Reserved scents of blackberry, oak and dust. Tart flavors of plum and orange zest. Wood dominates the close. $35
93 Da Vinci, 2000 Brunello di Montalcino
Brunello di Montalcino
Reserved aromas of cherry, pencil, cedar and dust. Tangy acidity and ripe tannins frame perfectly balanced flavors of dried cherry, nutmeg, mocha and brown sugar that sweeten up considerably with airing. Youthful kick in the finish. $70
86 Frescobaldi, 2003 Rèmole
Toscana IGT
Pungent damp stone aromas push the fruit to the background. Livens up on the palate with flavors of cherry and char. Cherry skin notes in the close. $10
86 Frescobaldi, 2001 Castello di Pomino
Pomino Rosso
Fresh cranberry, strawberry, tea and menthol aromas. Dry with raspy tannins and cherry flavors that eventually surface in the bone-dry finish. $25
91 Frescobaldi, 2001 Lucente
Toscana IGT
Spicy nose of pekoe tea, resin and mint. Woodsy flavors include oak, cedar, cherry and a note of iodine. Sweet, creamy close with a maple syrup-like sweetness. $28
92 Frescobaldi, 2001 Luce
Toscana IGT
Front-row aromas of mint, plum, cherry, charcoal and mocha. Supple chocolate flavors followed by plum and prune notes. Lingering, herbal finish. $75
90 Frescobaldi, 2000 Castelgiocondo
Brunello di Montalcino
Sweet pecan aromas with oak, citrus peel and a whiff of resin. Crisp cranberry flavors spiked with drying tannins and a vibrant menthol-like influence. Crisp, peppery finish. $60
88 Frescobaldi, 2001 Lamaione Merlot
Castelgiocondo, Toscana IGT
Intense aromas of date, plum, oak, maple and minerals. Flavors of red fruit, citrus and fruitcake spice. Lean close. $75
90 Frescobaldi, 2001 Mormoreto
Castello di Nipozzano, Toscana IGT
Perfumed, subtly sweet aromas of cherry, new oak and dried tobacco. Tangy flavors of red berry, rose petals, minerals and cedar are tarter than suggested by the nose. Long finish. $50
88 Gabbiano, 2000 Alleanza
Toscana IGT
Rich aromas of fig, blackberry, pencil shavings and brown sugar. Flavors of tart cherry, coffee and cedar drop off a bit in the mouth. Drying finish. $35
89 Gabbiano, 2000 Bellezza
Toscana IGT
Shy scents of orange, graphite and earth. Balanced, mature flavors of dried cherry and brown sugar. Puckering close. $30
87 Gabbiano, 2003 Sangiovese/Merlot
Toscana IGT
Forward grapy and smoky aromas. Vibrant flavors of sour cherry and cedar. Vivacious finish. $10
89 Ornellaia, 2003 Le Volte
Toscana IGT
Deep aromas of brown spice, coffee and cedar jettison the fruit to the background. Balanced, nicely lean flavors of cherry pit and bittersweet chocolate. Compact close shows drying tannins. $25
92 Ornellaia, 2002 Le Serre Nuove
Bolgheri
Subtle aromas of smoke and herbs wrap around a bright cherry core. Vibrant, expressive, citrusy flavors of cherry and sweet oak. Long, polished finish oozes fruit. $50
Other Reds
89 Cantine Mucci, 2002 Cantico
Montepulciano d'Abruzzo
Scents of brambly blackberry, smoke, treacle and minerals. Intense flavors of black plum, espresso and baker's chocolate. Long finish features mocha. $35
87 Dievole/Muñoz, 1999 Plenum Tertius
Spain/Italy
Aromas of plum, licorice and sawdust. Balanced flavors of blackberry and earth. An espresso note picks up the close. $28
91 Rainoldi, 1999 Fruttaio Ca' Rizzieri
Valtellina Sfursat
Floral scents of sweet cherry, dust, brown sugar and forest floor. Intensely sweet, though balanced, flavors of sugared plum, maple and wood. Fruit compote in the lingering finish. $65
91 Terre degli Svevi, 2000 Re Manfredi
Aglianico del Vulture
Nuanced aromas of red berry, dried herbs, tar and cedar. Well-evolved flavors of red fruit, loam and wood spice. Long, layered finish. $30
88 Umberto Cesari, 2002 Riserva
Sangiovese di Romagna
Peppery aromas of red fruit and tar. Soft flavors of cherry, earth and oak. Raspberry notes sweeten up the close. $17
89 Umberto Cesari, 2001 Sangiovese/Cabernet
Liano, Rubicone IGT
Warm aromas of fig, fruitcake spice, tar and a coconut note. Smooth flavors of blackberry and earth. Somewhat tart finish. $32
85 Fourplay, 2001 Fourplay N° 1
Sicilia IGT
$12
Dry Creek Zins
On August 10, Contributing Editor Gerald D. Boyd attended a two-day exploration of Dry Creek Valley wines hosted by the Winegrowers of Dry Creek Valley, in Sonoma County. What follows are tasting notes and comments from a three-flight, tutored tasting of Dry Creek Zinfandels. The wines were not tasted blind. Word scores are based on the BuyLine rating system.
Flight 1: Dry Creek Valley Terroir. The intention of this flight of wines was to show the influences of terroir aspects such as the nearby Pacific Ocean, fog and soils, but that intention was trumped by winemaking. As Mick Unti, one of the winemakers aptly put it, "The winemaking masks the aspects of terroir."
Bella Vineyards, 2002 Zinfandel
Belle Canyon Estate, Dry Creek Valley
Light berry nose, jammy back note, with hints of vanilla; firm structure, dark fruit, nicely integrated tannins. $30 Very Good
Mauritson Wines, 2002 Zinfandel
Rockpile, Dry Creek Valley
Ripe blackberry aromas, spicy back note; richly textured, concentrated berry flavors, big chewy tannins, good acidity; long, concentrated finish. $29 Outstanding
Nalle, 2002 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Lovely, ripe raspberry and spice nose; forward, juicy, ripe berry flavors, gentle spice notes, balancing acidity; long finish with ample fruit. $26 Superb
Preston of Dry Creek, 2002 Zinfandel
Old Vines/Old Clones, Dry Creek Valley
Slightly closed vanilla and spice aromas, tight berry back notes; good texture with jammy fruit and firm tannins. $24 Very Good
Quivira, 2002 Zinfandel
Anderson Ranch, Dry Creek Valley
Shy nose, medium berry and spice; rich texture, fills out with subtle jammy notes; medium finish with juicy fruit notes. $30 Very Good
Peterson Winery, 2002 Zinfandel
Bradford Mountain Vineyard, Dry Creek Valley
Low-intensity berry aromas, earthy notes; bright acidity, lean berry flavors, hint of vanilla; short finish. $25 Good
Flight 2: Blending vs. 100 percent Zinfandel. Although other varieties were used as blenders in some of these wines, the most common thread was petite sirah. Doug Nalle explained why Zinfandel should be blended: "What is missing in Zinfandel is the middle, so we need something, like petite sirah, to fill [it in]."
Amphora Wines, 2002 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Inviting ripe blackberry and spice aromas; medium fruit, concentrated, slightly jammy, mineral note; rich finish with a touch of bitterness; blended with 10 percent petite sirah. $28 Outstanding
David Coffaro, 2002 My Zin
Dry Creek Valley
Low intensity cherry-berry nose, vanilla and grainy earth notes; light berry flavors, herbal back notes; blended with 19 percent petite sirah and 6 percent cabernet sauvignon. $22 Good
Ridge, 2002 Zinfandel
Lytton Springs, Dry Creek Valley
Forward dark berry aromas; excellent balance, subtle spicy berry flavors, integrated American oak, firm tannins; long finish; blended with 20 percent petite sirah, 5 percent carignane. $30 Outstanding
Talty Vineyards & Winery, 2002 Estate Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Inviting medium nose, ripe raspberry and spice; excellent structure, firm but not overly assertive tannins; good length; 100 percent zin. $32 Outstanding
Unti Vineyards, 2002 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Bright, slightly jammy berry nose; dry, medium fruit, great texture and balance; crisp acidity, long fruity finish; blended with 8 percent petite sirah, 6 percent barbera. $22 Outstanding
Mill Creek, 2002 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Ripe berry and spice nose; good texture, forward fruit, American oak (dill pickle) notes; old-style Zin; 100 percent zinfandel. $25 Very Good
Flight 3: Baring the Soul of Dry Creek Valley Zinfandel. The object of this flight was for six of the wineries to present their best offerings. Prices, where given, were as of release.
Bella Vineyards, 2002 Zinfandel
Lily Hill Estate, Dry Creek Valley
Vibrant berry and spice nose, berry jam notes; dense, tactile fruit flavors, rich chewy tannins, dark plum; slightly astringent finish. $30 Very Good
Nalle, 1999 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Deeply layered nose, ripe blackberry and spice; medium berry flavors are tired and a little dried out; medium finish and fruit. $25 Good
Preston of Dry Creek, 2001 Zinfandel
Old Vines/Old Clones, Dry Creek Valley
Forward jammy nose, dense blackberry and spice notes; good structure, balanced tannins, berry flavors; long, intense finish. $24 Outstanding
Ridge, 1995 Zinfandel
Lytton Springs, Dry Creek Valley
Upfront blackberry jam nose, hints of clove; smoky oak, dense berry flavors, good supporting tannins and acidity; long finish shows finesse. $N/A Outstanding
Peterson Winery, 1994 Zinfandel
Bradford Mountain Vineyard, Dry Creek Valley
Forward leafy nose, hints of blackberry; light fruit, faint berry notes, high acidity; medium finish and fruit. $N/A Good
Unti Vineyards, 2003 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Medium red berry nose, spicy back notes; rich, concentrated, slightly jammy flavors, dark fruit, firm tannins; long, balanced finish. $22 Outstanding
Greg Norman
The following wines were reviewed by BuyLine panelist Abraham Horowitz on August 16 at North One 10 in Miami, Florida, with Greg Norman California Estates winemaker Ron Schrieve. The wines were not tasted blind.
89 Greg Norman Estates, 2004 Chardonnay
Santa Barbara
Crisp scents of green apple, white peach and minerals. Juicy flavors of peach and Granny Smith apple have a touch of creaminess. Sweet pineapple notes in the close. $13
90 Greg Norman Estates, 2004 Pinot Noir
Santa Barbara
Intense aromas of cherry pie, vanilla, lavender and brown sugar. Juicy flavors of raspberry and wild cherry. Silky tannins and hints of allspice in the lingering finish. $15
92 Greg Norman Estates, 2003 Petite Sirah
Paso Robles
Beautiful purple hue. Enticing scents of plum and dark chocolate with a hint of leather. Plush tannins and ripe flavors of blackberry and black cherry. Hints of vanilla in the raspberry-imbued close. $15
88 Greg Norman Estates, 2003 Cabernet
North Coast
Complex scents of blackberry, green olive and herbes de Provence with secondary nuances of dust and tea. Juicy flavors of raspberry and cassis with hints of dust and bitter chocolate in the finish. $15
87 Greg Norman Estates, 2003 Zinfandel
Lake County
Scents of blackberry, fig and black pepper. Powerful, gritty tannins and jammy flavors of blackberry and black cherry. Wild cherry close is very lively. $15
Guigal
The following wines were tasted by Executive Editor Todd Wernstrom on February 27 at the 20th Annual Great Wine Seminar in Miami, Florida. The seminar, one of a series held over the course of the weekend, was moderated by Michael Broadbent, M.W. and Guigal importer Frederick Ek. A selection of the wines are presented in the order they were poured and were not tasted blind. Prices are current retail.
90 Guigal, 2003 La Doriane
Condrieu
Very varietal aromas of apricot and honey. Soft, unctuously textured flavors of peach preserves and baking spices are a bit shy of acidity. $72
93 Guigal, 1994 La Doriane
Condrieu
Burnished gold hue. Mature, layered scents of orange marmalade and cinnamon dough. Flavors of dried apricot and wood spice are leaner than suggested by the nose. $225
97 Guigal, 2001 Ex-Voto Blanc
Hermitage
Very perfumed aromas of apricot, pineapple and butterscotch are hugely expressive. A honeyed texture frames ample, classic flavors of stone fruit, wood spice and custard. A brilliant combination of nuance and power; as good a white Rhône as one could ever hope to drink. $150
91 Guigal, 1999 Brune et Blonde
Côte-Rôtie
Big, warm aromas of plum, chocolate and vanillin oak. Youthful, somewhat reserved flavors of plum, red berry, black pepper and a chocolate note. $60
93 Guigal, 1999 La Mouline
Côte-Rôtie
Young aromas of roasted plum, smoke and tar. A pretty mocha note leads to flavors of mixed berries, black earth, cedar and licorice. A currently compact wine in need of time to show its true colors. $550
95 Guigal, 1999 La Landonne
Côte-Rôtie
Perfumed aromas of red berry, dried tobacco and anise. Meaty flavors of earth, tar, black pepper and cedar are layered and dense, and at present, have relegated the fruit to the background. $580
95 Guigal, 1999 La Turque
Côte-Rôtie
Vanillin oak scents leap from the glass and then settle down to cherry and bittersweet chocolate. Flavors of cherry, orange and chocolate are framed by smooth tannins, making this single vineyard offering the most forward of the three '99s. $495
94 Guigal, 1998 La Turque
Côte-Rôtie
Lively, peppery aromas of blackberry, grill pan and a roasted nuance. Very concentrated flavors of black fruit, licorice, grilled meat and chocolate. $310
95 Guigal, 1997 La Mouline
Côte-Rôtie
Very fragrant aromas of mixed berries, sweet oak and lots of milk chocolate. Rich, chewy, peppery flavors of blackberry, wood notes and tar. Still quite vibrant and youthful. $300
92 Guigal, 1990 La Landonne
Côte-Rôtie
Light garnet hue with a faded rim. Lean, earthy aromas of red fruit and wood. A roasted fruit nuance adds to flavors that replicate the nose. Soft texture cushions the wine's obvious decline. $700
95 Guigal, 1988 La Mouline
Côte-Rôtie
Light garnet hue with an orange rim. Lively aromas of dried cherry, licorice and lots of smoke. Velvety texture frames ample flavors of black pepper, grilled meat and red fruit notes. $550
96 Guigal, 1985 La Turque
Côte-Rôtie
Medium garnet hue to the rim. Perfumed aromas of cooked cherry, anise and a smoke note. Intense flavors of licorice and smoked meat are kept fresh by a pronounced citrus-spiked acidity. A wine with much more life left. $700
96 Guigal, 1985 La Mouline
Côte-Rôtie
Light garnet hue with a faded rim. Beautifully integrated aromas of raspberry, cedar, menthol and smoke. Tangy, youthful flavors of red cherry, citrus and milk chocolate are long and layered. $695
96 Guigal, 1983 La Mouline
Côte-Rôtie
Light ruby hue with a faded rim. Surprisingly vibrant aromas of red berry, forest floor, cedar, black pepper and grill pan. Intense, though mature, flavors of citrus, licorice, smoke and red fruit notes. A remarkably expressive effort. $450
93 Guigal, 1978 La Landonne
Côte-Rôtie
Medium garnet hue with a faded rim. Aged aromas of cherry compote, brown sugar, chocolate and barnyard. Similar flavors, minus the barnyard, have a velvety mouth-feel. $750
About the BuyLine Panel: More than 100 wines are reviewed in every issue of Wine News. All wines are tasted double-blind and each entry is evaluated and scored based upon individual merit. Wines that score above 70 points are recommended in the BuyLine. Tasting and interpreting wine is a purely subjective exercise; all scores and accompanying tasting notes represent the collective opinions of our panel.
Wine Samples: Send samples for review with retail price affixed to:
Wine News BuyLine Tasting Panel
1501 Venera Avenue, Suite 320
Coral Gables, FL 33146
Telephone: 305.740.7170
The Panel: Maurice Adams, specialty food and wine merchant; Lyn Farmer, senior staff columnist; Abraham Horowitz, BuyLine panelist; Tom E. Smith, publisher; John Stroker, BuyLine panelist; Fred Tasker, Miami Herald wine critic; Todd M. Wernstrom, executive editor.
Scoring: Tasting notes reflect the panel's collective impressions; scores are averaged and represent the panel's mean. Wines possessing certain criteria will be singled out for special recognition:
Taster's Choice: Wines which display outstanding quality, character and potential.
Best Value Wines of exceptional quality which sell at a moderate price.
Stemware: Riedel Ouverture tasting glasses.
Pricing: Prices vary from state to state. Retail prices listed are approximate.
